Who Is Stonegate?
Stonegate Insurance is a personal-lines auto insurer headquartered in Niles, Illinois, just outside Chicago, and part of the Producers National Company group. It writes both standard and non-standard personal automobile insurance, along with targeted coverage for manufactured homes, light commercial vehicles owned by small businesses, and commercial trucks. Stonegate’s growth is built on partnerships with independent insurance agents, wholesalers, and managing general agents rather than direct-to-consumer sales. The company has modernized its operations on the Diamond policy-administration system.
Because Stonegate sells exclusively through independent agents — online quoting is not offered directly to consumers — it is a natural fit for an agency like Better Choice Insurance Group. We can quote Stonegate for clients who need affordable auto coverage, including drivers who fall outside a standard carrier’s guidelines. As an independent agency, we compare Stonegate’s rates against our full panel so you get competitive pricing for your situation.
What They’re Known For
- Standard & Non-Standard Auto: Writes both preferred and high-risk personal auto policies.
- Agent-Only Distribution: Sold exclusively through independent agents, wholesalers, and MGAs.
- Additional Coverages: Also offers manufactured-home, light commercial auto, and commercial truck insurance.
- Chicago-Area Insurer: Headquartered in Niles, Illinois as a Producers National company.
Quick Links
Where We Write Stonegate Insurance
Better Choice Insurance Group offers Stonegate coverage to clients across our service areas:
- Illinois: St. Charles, Naperville, Chicago, Aurora, Schaumburg
- Texas: San Antonio, Dallas, Houston, Austin, Fort Worth
- Indiana: Indianapolis, Carmel, Fishers
- Minnesota: Minneapolis, St. Paul, Bloomington
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Better Choice Insurance Group offer Stonegate insurance?
Yes. Better Choice Insurance Group is an independent insurance agency that offers Stonegate policies and compares them against 22+ carriers to find you the best coverage at the best price. Call (847) 908-5665 for a free quote.
Where can I get Stonegate insurance through Better Choice Insurance Group?
Carrier availability depends on your state, ZIP code and the details of your home or vehicle. Request a free quote online or call (847) 908-5665, and we'll confirm whether Stonegate can write your policy and compare it with the rest of our carrier panel.