Mon–Fri: 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
(847) 908-5665  |  [email protected]

Nationwide vs. Grange Home Insurance: A Midwest Agent's Comparison

November 2026  |  9 min read  |  By Evan Larson, Licensed Insurance Agent
Written and reviewed by Evan Larson, Licensed Insurance Agent  ·  Updated November 2026

Quick answer: Nationwide and Grange are both Columbus, Ohio insurers rated A (Excellent) by AM Best; the main difference is that Nationwide is national while Grange is a regional carrier that sells only through independent agents. Nationwide stands out for Brand New Belongings and Better Roof Replacement, Grange for matching materials and concealed water damage coverage. We quote both, so the better fit for your house comes down to a side-by-side quote.

Nationwide and Grange have more in common than most shoppers realize. Both are headquartered in Columbus, Ohio, both trace their roots to Ohio farm communities, and both now sell home insurance through independent agents. The difference is scale: Nationwide is a national insurer, while Grange deliberately stays regional.

We represent both companies, so we have no reason to steer you either way. Here is how they compare, using each company's own pages and dated third-party sources.

How Do Nationwide and Grange Compare at a Glance?

Category Nationwide Grange
Home office One Nationwide Plaza, Columbus, OH 671 South High Street, Columbus, OH
Footprint National; describes itself as one of the largest insurance and financial services companies in the U.S. Regional; "policyholders across 13 states," with home insurance in 11 states (with affiliate Integrity)
How you buy Online, by phone, or through an agent "Exclusively through independent agents"
Roof options Better Roof Replacement (optional) Matching materials for roof and siding; ACV roof coverage for a lower premium
Belongings and rebuild Brand New Belongings; Dwelling Replacement Cost up to 2x the dwelling limit Home replacement cost after a total loss; valuables, collectibles and jewelry
Water and systems Water backup, service line, equipment breakdown Sewer and drain backup, concealed water damage, service line, equipment breakdown
AM Best A (Excellent) for P&C companies; outlook revised to positive (reported Nov. 2026) "A" (Excellent), per Grange's board chair (Sept. 2026)
Can Better Choice quote it? Yes Yes

Sources: Nationwide newsroom, Nationwide homeowners, Nationwide coverages, InsuranceNewsNet on AM Best and Nationwide, Grange about, Grange home, Grange coverages, Insurance Business on Grange. Coverages vary by state and policy.

How Big Is Nationwide's Footprint Compared With Grange's?

Nationwide is national. Its newsroom marked "the centennial of the day it sold its first policy" on April 14, 2026, and describes Nationwide as "one of the largest and most diversified insurance and financial services companies in the United States." Its homeowners page lets you quote online, by phone, or through a local agent. In 2020, Insurance Journal reported Nationwide's announcement that "the process of transitioning the company to operate as an independent insurance agency carrier is complete."

Grange is regional by design. Its about page says "today we serve policyholders across 13 states," traces its roots to "insuring Central Ohio's farming community" more than 90 years ago, and says "We sell exclusively through independent agents." Its home insurance page says that together with its affiliate Integrity Insurance, it offers home insurance in Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kentucky, Minnesota, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, Virginia and Wisconsin. Insurance Business reported in September 2026 that Grange works with more than 4,000 independent agents.

What does footprint mean for you? A national carrier spreads its risk across many regions and may matter if you own property in several states. A regional carrier concentrates on fewer markets and the agents who know them. Neither is better on its own. Whether either will write your house depends on underwriting for that address, so ask your agent.

What Home Coverage Options Does Each Offer?

Both write the standard pieces: dwelling, other structures, personal property, liability, and loss of use. The useful differences are in the optional coverages.

Nationwide

  • Brand New Belongings: pays to repair or replace covered possessions "regardless of age or condition," per Nationwide's homeowners page. You receive the depreciated value first, then the difference once you send receipts.
  • Better Roof Replacement: after a covered loss, the roof can be rebuilt "with stronger, safer roofing materials," according to its coverage page.
  • Dwelling Replacement Cost: "can pay up to two times your dwelling coverage limit if your home needs to be rebuilt after a loss."
  • Also listed: water backup, service line, equipment breakdown, Valuables Plus, earthquake (with a separate deductible), identity theft, and separate flood insurance.

Grange

  • Matching materials: "Replaces roofing or siding with matching materials," and if the originals aren't available, pays for full replacement with the closest match, per Grange's coverages page.
  • Concealed water damage: "Restore your home after hidden water damage."
  • Back up of sewers and drains: for a failed sump pump or a sewer or drain backup.
  • Also listed: home replacement cost after a covered total loss, underground service line, equipment breakdown, identity theft, personal cyber, valuables and jewelry, umbrella, and assisted living care for a relative's belongings.

Both companies say coverages vary by state and that the policy language controls. Before comparing prices, confirm the replacement cost terms on both quotes.

Which Discounts Do Nationwide and Grange Offer?

  • Nationwide (discounts page): multi-policy, protective device, claims-free, home renovation credit, roof rating, home purchase (bought "within the last 12 months"), prior insurance, gated community, and a smart home program that is "not available in all states."
  • Grange (home page and savings tips): multi-policy, prompt payer, home buyer, paid in full, central-station burglar and fire alarm discounts, and a home maintenance discount with proof of permits and inspections. Grange also says customers "could save up to 20%" with actual cash value roof coverage.

That last option deserves a caution. ACV roof coverage lowers the premium because a roof claim pays the depreciated value, not the cost of a new roof. On an older roof that gap can be thousands of dollars. Read our guide to ACV vs. replacement cost on roofs before choosing it. For more ways to save, see home insurance discounts and how to lower your home insurance premium.

How Financially Strong Are Nationwide and Grange?

Nationwide: InsuranceNewsNet reported on November 9, 2026 that AM Best "has changed its outlook for Nationwide's property and casualty business to positive from stable," with the rating at A (Excellent).

Grange: in a September 2026 leadership announcement covered by Insurance Business, Grange's board chair said the company has been "consistently maintaining our A.M. Best 'A' (Excellent) rating." AM Best rates other companies with "Grange" in their names, so when you check, look for the Columbus, Ohio company and its affiliate Integrity.

Both ratings sit in AM Best's "Excellent" category. For complaint data, the NAIC's Consumer Insurance Search lets you look up information "by state, company, and insurance type for the past three years."

Who Fits Nationwide vs. Grange in Illinois and Ohio?

Midwest homes share the same problems: hail and wind on roofs, sump pumps in basements, and older service lines. Here is how we think about fit, subject to each carrier's underwriting for the address.

Nationwide often fits homeowners who:

  • Want Brand New Belongings for contents, or Dwelling Replacement Cost for extra rebuild protection.
  • Want a roof upgraded to stronger materials after a covered loss through Better Roof Replacement.
  • Own property in several states, or want a smart home program.

Grange often fits homeowners who:

  • Have siding or roofing that would be hard to match after a partial loss.
  • Worry about slow, hidden leaks and want concealed water damage coverage.
  • Prefer a regional carrier that sells only through independent agents.
  • Want to lower premium with ACV roof coverage and understand the tradeoff.

For context, the NAIC Homeowners Insurance Report puts the average Illinois HO-3 premium at $1,480 for 2023; see our Illinois home insurance page. Ohio homeowners can start with our Ohio home insurance page. Either way, your quote depends on your house, not the average.

Get Both Quoted

Because we represent both carriers, we can quote Nationwide and Grange side by side with one form, along with Travelers, Liberty Mutual (formerly Safeco), Mercury, Progressive, and the rest of our 22+ carrier panel. We match dwelling limits, deductibles, and endorsements so the comparison is fair. Pair home with auto through our bundled home and auto quotes.

Our quick quote form takes about three minutes, and a licensed agent calls you back. For our clients, we review every renewal and re-shop when an increase is out of line. See also Travelers vs. Nationwide and the best home insurance companies in Illinois.

Want Nationwide and Grange quoted side by side? We represent both. Send us your current declarations page and we'll match the coverage across 22+ carriers. Free, no obligation; the online form takes about three minutes. Rated 4.9 stars on Google from 130+ reviews.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Nationwide or Grange better for home insurance?

Neither is better for every home. Both are rated A (Excellent) by AM Best and both are based in Columbus, Ohio. Nationwide is national and offers options like Brand New Belongings and Better Roof Replacement. Grange is regional, sells only through independent agents, and offers matching materials and concealed water damage coverage. Price depends on your house, so quote both.

Where does Grange offer home insurance?

Grange's website says that together with its affiliate Integrity Insurance it offers home insurance in Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kentucky, Minnesota, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, Virginia and Wisconsin. Whether Grange will write a specific home depends on underwriting for that address, so ask your agent.

What AM Best ratings do Nationwide and Grange have?

Both are in AM Best's Excellent category. InsuranceNewsNet reported in November 2026 that AM Best rates Nationwide's property and casualty business A (Excellent) and revised its outlook to positive from stable. Grange's board chair said in September 2026 that Grange maintains an A.M. Best A (Excellent) rating. Check AM Best for current ratings.

Does Grange really offer a discount for ACV roof coverage?

Grange says customers could save up to 20% on their home premium with actual cash value roof coverage. The tradeoff is that a roof claim pays the roof's depreciated value rather than the cost of a new roof, which can leave a large gap on an older roof. Ask your agent to price both options before choosing.

Can one agent quote both Nationwide and Grange?

Yes. Better Choice Insurance Group represents both carriers, so one form gets you side-by-side quotes from Nationwide, Grange, and the rest of our 22+ carrier panel with matching limits and deductibles. Quotes are free with no obligation, and our online form takes about three minutes before a licensed agent calls you back.

Related Reading

About the author

Evan Larson — Licensed Insurance Agent at Better Choice Insurance Group, an independent insurance agency in St. Charles, Illinois licensed in 14 states.

Last reviewed: November 2026

Nationwide or Grange? See Both Prices Side by Side.

We represent both carriers and 20+ more, and we match your coverage line by line.

Get Your Free Quote