Quick answer: Allstate and Progressive both hold an A+ (Superior) AM Best rating, so the real differences are how you buy and how each prices your driving. Allstate sells through its own agents and direct channels and offers both Drivewise and pay-per-mile Milewise; Progressive sells online and through independent agents like us and offers Snapshot. Neither is automatically cheaper, so quote identical coverage with both.
Allstate and Progressive are both household names in car insurance, and both run heavy advertising aimed at the same shoppers. Underneath, the buying experience is different: Allstate sells through its own agents and direct channels, while Progressive also sells through independent agencies.
Our disclosure: Better Choice Insurance Group quotes Progressive, but we do not sell Allstate. Allstate is a captive carrier, so we can't quote an Allstate policy, but we can quote Progressive and the other carriers below against your current Allstate policy. Everything here comes from each company's own pages and dated third-party sources.
How Do Allstate and Progressive Compare at a Glance?
| Category | Allstate | Progressive |
|---|---|---|
| How you buy | Allstate agents, online, or by phone | Online, by phone, or through "more than 40,000 independent insurance agents and insurance brokers" |
| Driving-behavior program | Drivewise (Allstate mobile app) | Snapshot (Progressive app or plug-in device) |
| Pay-per-mile option | Milewise: a daily rate plus a per-mile rate, measured by a plug-in device | None listed on the pages we reviewed |
| Published program figures | Drivewise: enrollment discount that "varies by state"; no national figure published | Snapshot: $164 average discount at sign-up; $328 average at completion |
| Can the program raise your rate? | Yes, for frequent risky driving (Allstate notes an exception for NY) | Yes; rates "could increase with high-risk driving" |
| AM Best financial strength | A+ (Superior), affirmed September 2, 2026; outlook stable | A+ (Superior), affirmed May 1, 2026; outlook stable |
| Can Better Choice quote it? | No (captive carrier) | Yes |
Sources: Allstate auto, Allstate Drivewise, Allstate Milewise, Progressive agent site, Progressive Snapshot, AM Best release on Allstate, AM Best release on Progressive. Terms vary by state; figures as published in November 2026.
How Do You Buy Allstate vs. Progressive?
Allstate lets you quote online, call a licensed representative, or work with a local Allstate agent, according to its auto insurance page. Those agents represent Allstate's own products. That's convenient if you want one company for everything, but an Allstate agent can't show you what another carrier would charge for the same coverage.
Progressive sells directly online and by phone, and through independent agencies. Its agent site says "We work with more than 40,000 independent insurance agents and insurance brokers countrywide." Buying Progressive through an independent agent means the same conversation can price other carriers too. Our page on independent vs. captive agents explains the difference.
One detail many shoppers don't know: Allstate also owns National General, which sells through independent agents. National General's website describes itself as "National General, an Allstate company," with "a network of more than 55,000 independent agents across the country." We do quote National General, but it is a separate company with its own policies, not an Allstate-brand policy.
What Coverage Options Does Each Company Offer?
Both companies write the standard coverages: liability, collision, comprehensive, and uninsured/underinsured motorist. The add-ons are where they differ.
Allstate's auto page lists rideshare insurance and roadside assistance, and its discounts page describes Accident Forgiveness, a policy feature that can keep your rate from rising after an at-fault accident, subject to the terms where you live.
Progressive's coverage guide lists rental reimbursement, roadside assistance, rideshare coverage where available, loan/lease payoff that "pays up to 25% of your vehicle's actual cash value toward your remaining balance," and custom parts and equipment coverage "typically up to a $5,000 limit." If you owe more than the car is worth, compare that with gap insurance.
Whichever carrier you choose, set liability limits first. Our Illinois auto insurance requirements guide shows why state minimums are rarely enough.
Drivewise and Milewise vs. Snapshot: How Do the Programs Differ?
Allstate offers two programs where Progressive offers one, and they answer different questions. Drivewise and Snapshot ask how you drive. Milewise asks how much you drive.
Allstate Drivewise
- How it works: the Allstate mobile app records your trips, according to the Drivewise page, and it can be added to a policy at no cost.
- Discount: an enrollment discount that varies by state, plus a participation discount. To keep it, at least one driver must take "at least 50 trips" before renewal.
- What raises your price: Allstate names speeding, sudden braking, phone activity, and late-night driving. Frequent risky driving can raise rates "(except NY)."
- Extra: free crash detection that prompts you to call 911, request roadside help, or start a claim.
Allstate Milewise
- How it works: per the Milewise page, it "uses a device to capture the miles you drive," and you track driving and costs in the Allstate app.
- Pricing: Pay-Per-Mile vehicles pay a daily rate plus a per-mile rate; "Unlimited" vehicles pay only a daily rate. You can mix both on one policy. Allstate does not publish the rates on that page.
- Who it suits: the tagline says it plainly: "Don't drive much? Don't pay much." Remote workers and second cars are the usual candidates.
Progressive Snapshot
- How it works: the Progressive app or a plug-in device, according to the Snapshot page.
- What it measures: hard braking, fast acceleration, phone use (app only, in some states), late-night driving, mileage, and consistency.
- Discount: a "$164 Average discount at program sign up" and a "$328 Average discount at program completion."
- Can it go up? Yes; your rate "could increase with high-risk driving," though Progressive says "only about 2 out of 10 drivers actually get an increase."
None of these programs is offered in every state. Tell your agent how and how much you drive before enrolling in any of them.
Which Discounts Do Allstate and Progressive Advertise?
- Allstate (discounts page): anti-lock brakes, anti-theft device, responsible payer, good student (for a high school student with "a grade average of at least B-"), home and auto bundling, and Drivewise. Allstate says discount amounts vary and depend on the state.
- Progressive (discounts page): multi-car, with "Average savings of 12%"; good student, which "Starts at 5%"; multi-policy; continuous insurance; teen driver; homeowner; paperless; pay in full; automatic payment; and online quote and sign-online discounts, some of which depend on how you buy.
Discounts matter less than the final premium for the same coverage. If you own a home, price home and auto together; see whether bundling is worth it.
How Financially Strong Are Allstate and Progressive?
AM Best. Both carry an A+ (Superior) financial strength rating with a stable outlook. AM Best affirmed the A+ rating of the members of Allstate Insurance Group on September 2, 2026, and affirmed the A+ rating of Progressive's main insurers on May 1, 2026. Check AM Best for current ratings before you buy.
J.D. Power. The 2026 U.S. Auto Insurance Study press release (June 9, 2026) lists the highest-ranking insurer in each region; it does not name Allstate or Progressive among them. In the North Central region, which includes Illinois, it names Erie Insurance (688).
Complaints. The NAIC's Consumer Insurance Search lets you look up information "by state, company, and insurance type for the past three years." Compare several companies rather than relying on one number.
Who Is Each Company a Good Fit For?
Allstate often fits drivers who:
- Want a local captive agent and one company for car and home.
- Drive very little and want true pay-per-mile pricing through Milewise.
- Value Accident Forgiveness and crash detection in the app.
Progressive often fits drivers who:
- Want the choice of buying online or through an independent agent.
- Have a financed car or aftermarket parts and want loan/lease payoff or custom parts coverage.
- Drive in a way Snapshot rewards; see our Progressive carrier page.
We leave price off both lists deliberately. It changes with your ZIP code, vehicle, driving record, and credit-based insurance score, so the only fair comparison is identical limits and deductibles, quoted the same week.
Get Both Quoted
We can't quote Allstate, but you already have its price on your declarations page. Send it to us and we will quote Progressive, Travelers, Liberty Mutual (formerly Safeco), Nationwide, Grange, Mercury, National General, and the rest of our 22+ carrier panel side by side with one form. If Allstate is still your best value, keeping it is a sound decision.
Our quick quote form takes about three minutes, and a licensed agent calls you back. Leaving? Our guide to switching from Allstate covers timing so there's no lapse, and Allstate's Illinois rate news explains recent changes. See also State Farm vs. Progressive.
Have an Allstate policy now? Send us your declarations page and we'll quote Progressive and 20+ other carriers against it. Free, no obligation; the online form takes about three minutes. Rated 4.9 stars on Google from 130+ reviews.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Allstate or Progressive better for car insurance?
Neither is better for everyone. Both hold an A+ (Superior) financial strength rating from AM Best. Allstate suits drivers who want a local captive agent or pay-per-mile pricing through Milewise; Progressive suits drivers who want to buy online or through an independent agent and may want add-ons like loan/lease payoff. Price depends on your household, so quote both.
Can an independent agent quote Allstate?
No. Allstate sells through its own agents and direct channels, so Better Choice Insurance Group cannot quote an Allstate policy. We can quote Progressive and the rest of our 22+ carrier panel against your current Allstate policy, including National General, which is an Allstate company sold through independent agents.
What is the difference between Drivewise, Milewise, and Snapshot?
Drivewise and Snapshot price part of your policy on how you drive, such as braking, speed, phone use, and late-night trips. Drivewise uses the Allstate app; Snapshot uses the Progressive app or a plug-in device. Milewise is Allstate's pay-per-mile option: a daily rate plus a per-mile rate, with miles captured by a plug-in device.
Can Drivewise or Snapshot raise my rate?
Yes. Allstate says frequent risky driving can raise rates under Drivewise, except in New York. Progressive says Snapshot rates could increase with high-risk driving, though it reports only about 2 out of 10 drivers get an increase. Ask your agent before enrolling if you drive late at night or brake hard often.
What AM Best ratings do Allstate and Progressive have?
Both are rated A+ (Superior) with a stable outlook. AM Best affirmed the rating for members of Allstate Insurance Group on September 2, 2026, and for Progressive's main insurers on May 1, 2026. Check AM Best for current ratings before you buy.
Related Reading
- Switching From Allstate: What to Know
- Better Choice vs. Allstate
- Allstate Illinois Rate News 2026
- State Farm vs. Progressive Auto Insurance
- Progressive vs. GEICO Auto Insurance
- How to Switch Auto Insurance Without a Lapse
About the author
Evan Larson — Licensed Insurance Agent at Better Choice Insurance Group, an independent insurance agency in St. Charles, Illinois licensed in 14 states.
Last reviewed: November 2026