Quick answer: State Farm and Progressive both hold an A+ (Superior) AM Best rating; the biggest difference is how you buy. State Farm sells through its own agents and website, while Progressive sells online, by phone, and through independent agents like us. Neither is automatically cheaper, so quote identical coverage with both before you decide.
State Farm and Progressive are two of the most familiar names in American car insurance, and shoppers compare them constantly. They are built very differently, though. State Farm sells through its own agents. Progressive sells online, by phone, and through independent agencies.
A plain disclosure before we start: Better Choice Insurance Group quotes Progressive, but we do not sell State Farm. State Farm sells only through its own agents, so we can't quote it, but we can quote Progressive and the other carriers below against your current State Farm policy. Everything below comes from each company's own pages and dated third-party ratings.
How Do State Farm and Progressive Compare at a Glance?
| Category | State Farm | Progressive |
|---|---|---|
| How you buy | State Farm agents or statefarm.com; the company says it has "over 19,000 auto insurance agents" | Online, by phone, or through "more than 40,000 independent insurance agents and insurance brokers" |
| Usage-based program | Drive Safe & Save (State Farm app plus a Bluetooth beacon) | Snapshot (Progressive app or a plug-in device) |
| Published program figures | 10% initial participation discount; savings "up to 30%" | $164 average discount at sign-up; $328 average at program completion |
| Can the program raise your rate? | Yes; the adjustment "may increase or decrease at each renewal" | Yes; rates "could increase with high-risk driving" |
| Notable optional coverages | Rental car reimbursement, travel expenses, emergency road service, rideshare driver coverage | Rental reimbursement, roadside, loan/lease payoff, custom parts and equipment, rideshare |
| AM Best financial strength | A+ (Superior), downgraded from A++ in November 2025; outlook stable | A+ (Superior), affirmed May 1, 2026; outlook stable |
| Can Better Choice quote it? | No (captive carrier) | Yes |
Sources: State Farm auto, State Farm Drive Safe & Save, State Farm coverage options, Progressive agent site, Progressive Snapshot, Progressive coverage guide, Insurance Journal on AM Best and State Farm, AM Best release on Progressive. Terms vary by state; figures as published in November 2026.
How Do You Buy State Farm vs. Progressive?
State Farm is a captive carrier. Its agents represent State Farm and only State Farm. You can also quote on statefarm.com, and its auto insurance page says "Across the nation, State Farm has over 19,000 auto insurance agents dedicated to providing you with personalized service." One local office for car, home, and life works well for many families; the tradeoff is that a State Farm agent cannot show you another company's price. (If you are unhappy with your agent but not the company, see how to switch State Farm agents.)
Progressive sells three ways. You can buy directly online or by phone, or through an independent agency. Its agent site says "We work with more than 40,000 independent insurance agents and insurance brokers countrywide." Buying through an independent agent means the same conversation can also price other carriers. For the difference between the two models, see our page on independent vs. captive agents.
What Coverage Options Does Each Company Offer?
The core coverages match: liability, collision, comprehensive, and uninsured/underinsured motorist. The differences are in the add-ons.
State Farm's coverage options page lists rental car reimbursement and travel expense coverage, which it says "helps pays for meals, lodging, and transportation if you're in an accident more than 50 miles from home." It also offers emergency road service and a rideshare driver option that "simply extends the coverage that you already have on your personal State Farm auto policy."
Progressive's coverage guide lists rental reimbursement, roadside assistance, rideshare coverage where available, and two add-ons that matter for financed or modified cars. Its loan/lease payoff coverage "pays up to 25% of your vehicle's actual cash value toward your remaining balance," and custom parts and equipment coverage is "typically up to a $5,000 limit." If you are upside down on a loan, compare that with gap insurance before you decide.
With either carrier, settle your liability limits first; our Illinois auto insurance requirements guide shows where the legal minimums fall short.
Drive Safe & Save vs. Snapshot: How Do the Usage-Based Programs Differ?
Both companies will price part of your policy on how you drive. Here is what each says on its own page.
State Farm Drive Safe & Save
- How it collects data: the State Farm app on your phone plus a Bluetooth beacon in the car, according to the Drive Safe & Save page.
- Discount: the page lists a 10% initial participation discount and says you could save "up to 30%," noting discounts "may exceed 30% and vary state-to-state."
- Can it go up? Yes. The adjustment is recalculated and "may increase or decrease at each renewal."
- Mileage: mileage counts, and the page notes low-mileage credits can be lost above 7,500 miles a year. It is not offered in every state.
Progressive Snapshot
- How it collects data: the Progressive app or a plug-in device, according to the Snapshot page.
- What it measures: hard braking, fast acceleration, phone use (app only, in some states), late-night driving, how much you drive, and consistency.
- Discount: Progressive lists a "$164 Average discount at program sign up" and a "$328 Average discount at program completion."
- Can it go up? Yes. Progressive says your rate "could increase with high-risk driving," adding that "only about 2 out of 10 drivers actually get an increase." It is not offered in every state.
Our take: smooth, low-mileage, daytime drivers tend to benefit from either program. Late-night commuters and hard brakers should ask before enrolling, because both programs can work against you.
Which Discounts Do State Farm and Progressive Advertise?
Both carriers advertise long discount lists, and both say discounts vary by state. Highlights from each company's own page:
- State Farm (discounts page): Good Student, which it says can "Save up to 25%"; a passive restraint discount "up to 40%" on medical-related coverage; the Steer Clear program for new drivers and drivers under 25; bundling; defensive driving; good driver; anti-theft; vehicle safety; driver training; and student away at school.
- Progressive (discounts page): multi-car, with "Average savings of 12%"; good student, which "Starts at 5%"; multi-policy; continuous insurance; teen driver; homeowner; paperless; pay in full; automatic payment; and online quote and sign-online discounts. Some of these depend on how you buy, so ask your agent which apply.
Discount lists rarely decide the comparison; the final premium does. Bundling can change the answer, so price home and auto together (see whether bundling is worth it).
How Financially Strong Are State Farm and Progressive?
AM Best. Both carry an A+ (Superior) financial strength rating. On May 1, 2026, AM Best affirmed the A+ (Superior) rating of Progressive's main insurers with a stable outlook. In November 2025, Insurance Journal reported that AM Best downgraded State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company and its affiliates "to A+ from A++," revising the outlook to stable from negative. Ratings change, so check AM Best for the latest before you buy.
J.D. Power. The 2026 U.S. Auto Insurance Study press release (June 9, 2026) names State Farm the highest-ranking insurer in the Northwest region, with a score of 667. The release does not name Progressive among the regional leaders. In the North Central region, which includes Illinois, it names Erie Insurance (688).
Complaints. For complaint data, use the NAIC's Consumer Insurance Search. The NAIC says you can "look up information by state, company, and insurance type for the past three years." Compare several companies, not just one.
Who Is Each Company a Good Fit For?
State Farm often fits drivers who:
- Want one local agent and one company for car, home, and life.
- Have a teen driver who can use the Good Student discount and Steer Clear program.
- Already bundle with State Farm and find the combined price competitive.
Progressive often fits drivers who:
- Want to choose between buying online and working with an independent agent.
- Have a financed car or aftermarket parts and want loan/lease payoff or custom parts coverage.
- Are comfortable with app-based tracking and drive in a way Snapshot rewards.
- Have specialty vehicles to add; see our Progressive carrier page.
Price is left off both lists on purpose: it flips with your ZIP code, vehicle, driving record, and credit-based insurance score. The only reliable comparison is a quote with identical limits and deductibles.
Get Both Quoted
We can't quote State Farm, but you can. Bring us your current State Farm declarations page and we will quote Progressive, Travelers, Liberty Mutual (formerly Safeco), Nationwide, Grange, Mercury, and the rest of our 22+ carrier panel side by side with one form. If State Farm is still your best value, keeping it is a sound decision.
Our quick quote form takes about three minutes, and a licensed agent calls you back. If you decide to switch, our guide to switching from State Farm covers timing so there is no lapse. More comparisons: Progressive vs. GEICO and Allstate vs. Progressive.
Have a State Farm policy now? Send us your declarations page and we'll quote Progressive and 20+ other carriers against it. Free, no obligation; the online form takes about three minutes. Rated 4.9 stars on Google from 130+ reviews.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is State Farm or Progressive better for car insurance?
Neither is better for everyone. Both hold an A+ (Superior) financial strength rating from AM Best. State Farm suits drivers who want one local captive agent for every policy; Progressive suits drivers who want to buy online or through an independent agent and may want add-ons like loan/lease payoff. Price depends on your household, so quote identical coverage with both.
Can an independent agent quote State Farm?
No. State Farm sells only through its own agents and its website. Better Choice Insurance Group cannot quote State Farm, but we can quote Progressive and the rest of our 22+ carrier panel against your current State Farm policy so you can compare.
What is the difference between Drive Safe & Save and Snapshot?
Drive Safe & Save uses the State Farm app plus a Bluetooth beacon, lists a 10% initial participation discount and savings up to 30%, and its adjustment may increase or decrease at each renewal. Snapshot uses the Progressive app or a plug-in device and lists a $164 average discount at sign-up and $328 at completion. Progressive says rates could increase with high-risk driving.
What AM Best ratings do State Farm and Progressive have?
Both are rated A+ (Superior). AM Best affirmed Progressive's A+ rating with a stable outlook on May 1, 2026. In November 2025, AM Best downgraded State Farm Mutual and its affiliates to A+ from A++ and revised the outlook to stable. Check AM Best for current ratings before you buy.
How do I compare my State Farm policy with Progressive?
Send us your State Farm declarations page. We will quote Progressive and other carriers with the same liability limits, deductibles, and add-ons so the comparison is apples to apples. Quotes are free and carry no obligation, and our online form takes about three minutes before a licensed agent calls you back.
Related Reading
- Thinking About Leaving State Farm? What Switching Looks Like
- Progressive vs. GEICO Auto Insurance
- Progressive vs. Safeco Auto Insurance
- Allstate vs. Progressive Auto Insurance
- Better Choice vs. State Farm
- How to Switch Auto Insurance Without a Lapse
About the author
Evan Larson — Licensed Insurance Agent at Better Choice Insurance Group, an independent insurance agency in St. Charles, Illinois licensed in 14 states.
Last reviewed: November 2026