Quick answer: Liberty Mutual (which retired the Safeco brand for independent agents in April 2026) and Travelers both sell home and auto insurance through independent agents, and we quote both. Travelers is rated A++ (Superior) by AM Best and Liberty Mutual A (Excellent). Neither is cheaper across the board; compare identical coverage, bundled and separately, to see which fits your household.
If you had a Safeco policy, your paperwork now says Liberty Mutual. If you are shopping home and auto insurance through an independent agent, Liberty Mutual and Travelers are two of the carriers you are most likely to see quoted side by side. We represent both, so this comparison is about fit, not about steering you to one.
Below: what the Safeco change means, how the two compare on financial strength, home and auto coverage, discounts and bundling, and how to compare quotes fairly.
What Happened to Safeco?
Liberty Mutual retired the Safeco brand in the independent agent channel effective April 25, 2026, and announced it on April 27, Insurance Journal reported. All personal lines products are now marketed and sold only as Liberty Mutual. Safeco customers keep their agent, and their policies stay the same.
Liberty Mutual bought Safeco in 2008, and Safeco had been its brand for independent agents, working with about 22,000 independent agencies, according to Insurance Journal's 2025 report on the planned change.
Writing for IA Magazine, Liberty Mutual's vice president of independent agent marketing said existing Safeco customers' policy, premiums and coverage stay the same, with no action required, and that agents will not sell the same products as Liberty Mutual's direct-to-customer channel: "the products will remain differentiated, just as they are today." That matters when you shop: what you read on Liberty Mutual's consumer website may not describe the policy an independent agent quotes you. We work from the actual quote.
Liberty Mutual vs. Travelers at a Glance
Every entry comes from the linked source. Where we could not verify a detail from a primary source, we say so.
| Category | Liberty Mutual (formerly Safeco) | Travelers |
|---|---|---|
| How it is sold | Independent agents (former Safeco channel) plus a separate direct channel with different products (IA Magazine) | Independent agents (Travelers) |
| AM Best financial strength | A (Excellent), affirmed September 10, 2025 (AM Best release) | A++ (Superior), affirmed August 21, 2026 (AM Best release) |
| Home optional coverages | Shown on your agent-channel quote; may differ from the direct product (IA Magazine) | Additional Replacement Cost Protection, water backup and sump pump, equipment breakdown, buried utility lines, identity fraud expense and more (Travelers) |
| Home discounts | Shown on your quote | Homebuyer, multi-policy, protective device, loss-free, green home up to 5% (Travelers) |
| Auto coverages | Shown on your quote | Liability, collision, comprehensive, loan or lease gap, extended transportation expenses (Travelers) |
| Auto discounts and telematics | Shown on your quote | Multi-policy, multicar, home ownership, safe driver, continuous insurance, hybrid/electric, new car, payment, early quote, student discounts; IntelliDrive telematics where offered (Travelers) |
| Existing Safeco policies | Policy, premiums and coverage unchanged; same agent (IA Magazine) | Not applicable |
Why so many "shown on your quote" cells? Liberty Mutual's agent-channel products differ from its direct ones, and its consumer website describes the direct products. Rather than describe the wrong product, we show you the endorsements and discounts on the actual Liberty Mutual quote.
How Do Liberty Mutual and Travelers Compare on Financial Strength?
AM Best affirmed the Financial Strength Rating of A (Excellent) for the members of Liberty Mutual Holding Company, with a stable outlook, in September 2025 (AM Best release). In August 2026, AM Best affirmed A++ (Superior), its highest rating, for the main Travelers subsidiaries, also with a stable outlook (AM Best release).
Travelers rates two notches higher on paper. Both ratings indicate a strong ability to pay claims; for most households, policy terms and price will matter more than the gap between A and A++.
How Does Home Coverage Compare?
Travelers' home coverage page lists these optional coverages: Additional Replacement Cost Protection (see extended replacement cost), Special Personal Property, Personal Property Replacement Cost, higher limits for certain valuables, Equipment Breakdown, Buried Utility Lines, Water Backup and Sump Pump Discharge or Overflow, Refrigerated Property, and Identity Fraud Expense Reimbursement.
For Liberty Mutual, we will show you the endorsement list on the agent-channel quote for your state and house. When comparing, line up the same items: extra replacement cost on the dwelling, water backup limit, service line or buried utility coverage, equipment breakdown, and scheduled jewelry. Then look at the roof: is it paid at replacement cost or actual cash value, and is there a separate wind/hail deductible? For more on a prior Safeco matchup, see Travelers vs. Safeco home insurance.
How Does Auto Coverage Compare?
Travelers' auto page lists liability, collision, comprehensive, loan or lease gap, and extended transportation expenses (rental car or alternate transportation after a covered accident). Its auto discounts page names multi-policy, multicar, home ownership (even if your home is insured elsewhere), a safe driver discount for three to five years without accidents, violations or major comprehensive claims, continuous insurance, hybrid/electric, new car, EFT, pay-in-full and good payer, early quote, good student, student away at school, and driver training. Travelers notes several are unavailable in some states.
Travelers also offers IntelliDrive, a telematics program that it says will "reward safer driving with savings," while riskier driving may raise premiums. It is subject to state availability.
For Liberty Mutual auto, compare the quote on the same limits: bodily injury and property damage liability, uninsured/underinsured motorist, collision and comprehensive deductibles, rental and towing, and any telematics enrollment. For other auto matchups, see Progressive vs. Safeco and Progressive vs. GEICO.
Should I Bundle Home and Auto With One of Them?
Both carriers write home and auto, and Travelers names a multi-policy discount on both its home and auto discount pages. Bundling often helps, but not always: sometimes the best home carrier and the best auto carrier for your household are different companies, and splitting wins. The test is the combined total for equal coverage. Our bundling guide and bundled home and auto quotes page walk through it.
What About Claims Service?
We won't grade claims handling from anecdotes. J.D. Power's 2026 U.S. Property Claims Satisfaction Study, released March 17, 2026, put average homeowners claims satisfaction at 702 on a 1,000-point scale (InsuranceNewsNet); the full brand chart is in J.D. Power's release. For complaint data, look up each company in the NAIC Consumer Insurance Search or contact your state Department of Insurance.
Who Is Each Company a Good Fit For?
Liberty Mutual may fit you if you are a former Safeco customer happy with your coverage and agent (nothing changes unless you want it to), or if its agent-channel quote for your home and cars comes in competitive on equal coverage, bundled or separately.
Travelers may fit you if you want its named home endorsements (Additional Replacement Cost Protection, buried utility lines, equipment breakdown), recently bought your home, own a LEED-certified home, have drivers who qualify for its safe driver or student discounts, or are comfortable with telematics through IntelliDrive. See also State Farm vs. Travelers and Allstate vs. Travelers.
How Do I Compare Liberty Mutual and Travelers Apples to Apples?
- Start from your current home declarations page and auto declarations page.
- Match dwelling limit, all-perils and wind/hail deductibles, roof settlement, and endorsements on the home quotes.
- Match liability limits, uninsured motorist limits, and collision and comprehensive deductibles on the auto quotes.
- Compare bundled totals and split totals.
- Check effective dates so nothing lapses.
Get Both Quoted
We quote Liberty Mutual and Travelers, along with Progressive, Nationwide, Grange, Mercury, and the rest of our 22+ carrier panel, side by side with one form. Our online quick quote takes about three minutes, and a licensed agent calls you back. Quotes are free with no obligation, and for our clients we review every renewal and re-shop when an increase is out of line.
Want Liberty Mutual and Travelers quoted on the same coverage? Independent agency, 22+ carriers, licensed in 14 states. Rated 4.9 stars on Google from 130+ reviews.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Safeco now Liberty Mutual?
Yes. Liberty Mutual retired the Safeco brand in the independent agent channel effective April 25, 2026, and now markets all personal lines products as Liberty Mutual. Safeco customers keep their agent, and their policies stay the same.
Did my Safeco policy change when it became Liberty Mutual?
According to Liberty Mutual's independent agent marketing team, existing Safeco customers' policy, premiums and coverage stay the same and no action is required. Only the brand on the policy changed. Your normal renewal terms still apply.
Is Liberty Mutual or Travelers better for home and auto insurance?
Neither is better for every household. Travelers is rated A++ (Superior) by AM Best and Liberty Mutual A (Excellent). The better choice depends on the price and terms each offers for your home and cars, so compare identical coverage, bundled and separately.
Are Liberty Mutual's agent products the same as its direct products?
No. Liberty Mutual says products sold through independent agents remain differentiated from its direct-to-customer products. That means its consumer website may not describe the policy an independent agent quotes, so compare from the actual quote.
Can Better Choice quote both Liberty Mutual and Travelers?
Yes. We are an independent agency and quote both, along with the rest of our 22+ carrier panel. The online quick quote takes about three minutes, a licensed agent calls you back, and quotes are free with no obligation.
Related Reading
- Travelers vs. Safeco Home Insurance
- Progressive vs. Safeco Auto Insurance
- Is Bundling Home and Auto Insurance Worth It?
- State Farm vs. Travelers Home Insurance
- Liberty Mutual: Carrier Profile
- Travelers: Carrier Profile
About the author
Evan Larson — Licensed Insurance Agent at Better Choice Insurance Group, an independent insurance agency in St. Charles, Illinois licensed in 14 states.
Last reviewed: November 2026