Mon–Fri: 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
(847) 908-5665  |  [email protected]

State Farm vs. Travelers Home Insurance: An Agent's Comparison

November 2026  |  9 min read  |  By Evan Larson, Licensed Insurance Agent
Written and reviewed by Evan Larson, Licensed Insurance Agent  ·  Updated November 2026

Quick answer: State Farm and Travelers are both large home insurers rated Superior by AM Best (Travelers A++, State Farm A+). The biggest practical difference is how you buy them: State Farm sells only through its own agents, while Travelers sells through independent agents who can price it next to other carriers. Neither is cheaper across the board; compare the same dwelling limit, deductibles and endorsements from your declarations page.

If you have a State Farm homeowners policy and a renewal on the way, you may be wondering how it stacks up against Travelers. Both are household names with strong financial strength ratings. The differences that matter are how you buy each one, which coverages and discounts each publishes, and what each says about wind, hail and roofs.

One disclosure up front: we are an independent agency. We quote Travelers. We do not sell State Farm. State Farm sells only through its own agents; we can't quote it, but we can quote Travelers and the other carriers on our panel against your current State Farm policy. Everything below about State Farm comes from State Farm's own pages or published reports, linked so you can check it.

What Is the Main Difference Between State Farm and Travelers?

Distribution. State Farm is a captive carrier: its agents represent State Farm and only State Farm. You can also start a quote on statefarm.com, but either way the only price you see is State Farm's.

Travelers sells through independent agents. In its own words, "some insurance agents work for only one company, so they can't offer you a choice of brands and policies," while "independent agents aren't held captive by one company" (Travelers). For you, that means a single conversation with an independent agent can put Travelers next to several other carriers for the same house.

State Farm vs. Travelers at a Glance

Every entry comes from the linked source. Where a company does not publish something, we say so.

Category State Farm Travelers
How it is sold Its own agents and statefarm.com (State Farm) Independent agents (Travelers)
AM Best financial strength A+ (Superior), lowered from A++ in November 2025 (Insurance Journal) A++ (Superior), affirmed August 21, 2026 (AM Best release)
Optional coverages it names Endorsements for things like earthquake damage and valuable collections; sewer backup by endorsement (State Farm) Additional Replacement Cost Protection, water backup and sump pump, equipment breakdown, buried utility lines, identity fraud expense and more (Travelers)
Discounts it names Multi-policy bundling, home security devices, claim-free history, roofing (State Farm) Homebuyer, multi-policy, protective device, loss-free, green home up to 5% (Travelers)
Wind/hail and roof Illinois customers now required to carry a minimum 1% wind/hail deductible; impact-resistant roof discounts in many states (State Farm) Not addressed on the Travelers deductible page we reviewed (Travelers); check the quote
Who can quote it for you A State Farm agent or statefarm.com An independent agent appointed with Travelers, including us

How Do State Farm and Travelers Compare on Financial Strength?

Both are rated in AM Best's "Superior" category. In August 2026, AM Best affirmed the Financial Strength Rating of A++ (Superior) for the main Travelers subsidiaries with a stable outlook, according to the AM Best release.

State Farm Mutual and its affiliates, including State Farm Fire and Casualty Company, were moved from A++ to A+ in November 2025. Insurance Journal reported that AM Best lowered its view of the group's operating performance from strong to adequate, citing elevated auto and homeowners loss ratios and weather losses, and revised the outlook to stable. A+ is still a "superior" rating under AM Best's methodology.

Both have the balance sheet to pay claims. A one-notch difference within Superior should not, on its own, decide where you insure your house.

What Coverage Options Does Each Company Offer?

Travelers

Travelers' home coverage page lists these optional coverages:

  • Additional Replacement Cost Protection, for when rebuilding costs rise above your dwelling limit (see extended replacement cost)
  • Special Personal Property and Personal Property Replacement Cost coverage
  • Higher limits for certain valuables
  • Equipment Breakdown coverage
  • Buried Utility Lines coverage
  • Water Backup and Sump Pump Discharge or Overflow coverage
  • Refrigerated Property coverage
  • Identity Fraud Expense Reimbursement coverage

State Farm

State Farm's public pages are less specific. Its homeowner guide describes endorsements as "optional add-ons that cover things like earthquake damage" and valuable collections, notes that sewer backup can be added by endorsement, and reminds readers that flood damage is not covered under most homeowners policies. For the full list available on your policy, ask your State Farm agent; it is also printed in the endorsements section of your declarations page.

For Midwest homes, the add-on we ask about first with any carrier is water backup coverage. A standard policy does not cover sump pump failures or sewer backups without it.

How Do They Handle Roofs and Wind/Hail?

This is where Illinois homeowners should look hardest. State Farm's Illinois issues page says "Illinois customers will now be required to have a minimum 1% Wind/Hail deductible." On a $400,000 dwelling limit, 1% is $4,000 out of pocket on a wind or hail claim. The same page says State Farm offers premium discounts to eligible homeowners in many states for qualifying impact-resistant roofing products.

Travelers' public deductibles page explains that you pay your deductible each time you have a covered loss, but does not describe a separate wind/hail deductible or a roof settlement rule. Terms vary by state and policy, so when we quote Travelers we show the wind/hail deductible and roof settlement terms on the quote itself, to line up against State Farm's. If roof settlement is new to you, read ACV vs. replacement cost on roof claims.

Which Discounts Do State Farm and Travelers Offer?

On its homeowners page, State Farm names bundling, home security devices, a claim-free history and roofing discounts. It also advertises that bundling home and auto could save "up to $1,429," which its footnote describes as average annual household savings from a 2025 State Farm survey of new policyholders who switched. That is a survey result, not a promise for your household.

Travelers' discounts page names a homebuyer discount (bought within 12 months before the policy starts), multi-policy, protective device (including smart or connected home technology that alerts you to fire or burglary), loss-free, and a green home discount of "up to 5%" for homes certified green by LEED.

Discount lists tell you what to ask about, not the final price, because each company starts from a different base rate. See our home insurance discounts guide.

What About Claims Service?

We won't grade claims handling from anecdotes. J.D. Power's 2026 U.S. Property Claims Satisfaction Study, released March 17, 2026, put average homeowners claims satisfaction at 702 on a 1,000-point scale (InsuranceNewsNet); the full brand-by-brand chart is in J.D. Power's release. For complaint data, look up each company in the NAIC Consumer Insurance Search and open its company report options, or contact your state Department of Insurance.

What Has State Farm Done in Illinois Recently?

State Farm is raising Illinois homeowners rates an average of 8%, effective October 1, 2026 for new business and December 1, 2026 for renewals, KFVS reported. Its Illinois page says homeowners claim costs ran "$1.26 for every dollar in premium we collected" last year; weather losses hit every carrier, so an increase is a reason to compare, not proof you are overpaying. We cover the details and a renewal checklist in State Farm's 8% Illinois increase.

Who Is Each Company a Good Fit For?

State Farm may fit you if you value working with one local agent for everything, you already bundle auto and home there and the combined price is competitive, or you have a long claims-free history the company is rewarding. If you are thinking about moving, our guides on switching from State Farm and switching State Farm agents cover both paths.

Travelers may fit you if you want its named endorsements (Additional Replacement Cost Protection, buried utility lines, equipment breakdown), recently bought your home, have qualifying protective devices, or own a LEED-certified home, or if you want several carriers priced at once. For other Travelers matchups, see Travelers vs. Safeco and Travelers vs. Nationwide.

How Do I Compare State Farm and Travelers Apples to Apples?

Start with your current declarations page. Any Travelers quote should match it on:

  1. Dwelling limit (Coverage A) and whether extra replacement cost is included
  2. All-perils deductible and the separate wind/hail deductible (a flat dollar amount vs. a percentage)
  3. Roof settlement: replacement cost or actual cash value
  4. Personal property on replacement cost, not actual cash value
  5. Liability limit, usually $300,000 or more
  6. Endorsements: water backup limit, service or buried lines, equipment breakdown, scheduled jewelry

A quote that is cheaper because it has a higher wind/hail deductible is a different product, not a better price. Our quote comparison guide walks through the traps.

Get Both Quoted

We can't quote State Farm, but we can quote Travelers, Liberty Mutual, Nationwide, Grange, and other carriers we represent side by side with one form, and compare them line by line against your State Farm declarations page. Our online quick quote takes about three minutes, and a licensed agent calls you back. Quotes are free with no obligation, and for our clients we review every renewal and re-shop when an increase is out of line. If State Farm is still your best value, we will say so.

Ready to see Travelers next to your State Farm renewal? Independent agency, 22+ carriers, licensed in 14 states. Mon–Fri, 9 AM–6 PM.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is State Farm or Travelers better for home insurance?

Neither is better for every household. Both hold AM Best ratings in the Superior range: Travelers A++ (affirmed August 2026) and State Farm A+ (lowered from A++ in November 2025). The right choice depends on the price and terms each offers for your home, so compare identical coverage from both.

Can an independent agent quote State Farm?

No. State Farm sells only through its own agents and its website, so an independent agency like Better Choice cannot quote it. We can quote Travelers and the other carriers we represent against your current State Farm declarations page so you can compare equal coverage.

Does State Farm require a wind/hail deductible in Illinois?

Yes. State Farm's Illinois newsroom page says Illinois customers will now be required to have a minimum 1% wind/hail deductible. On a $400,000 dwelling limit, that is $4,000 per wind or hail claim. Check the wind/hail line on your declarations page and match it when comparing quotes.

What optional coverages does Travelers offer on home policies?

Travelers lists Additional Replacement Cost Protection, Special Personal Property, Personal Property Replacement Cost, higher limits for certain valuables, Equipment Breakdown, Buried Utility Lines, Water Backup and Sump Pump Discharge or Overflow, Refrigerated Property, and Identity Fraud Expense Reimbursement coverage. Availability varies by state.

Is Travelers cheaper than State Farm?

There is no general answer. Each company weighs your roof, location, claims history and coverage choices differently, so the only way to know is to price identical coverage from both. We can quote Travelers; your State Farm price is on your renewal.

Related Reading

About the author

Evan Larson — Licensed Insurance Agent at Better Choice Insurance Group, an independent insurance agency in St. Charles, Illinois licensed in 14 states.

Last reviewed: November 2026

Compare Travelers Against Your State Farm Policy

We price your exact coverage across 22+ carriers and tell you honestly if your current rate is fair.

Get Your Free Quote