Quick answer: Mercury and Progressive are both agent-friendly auto carriers with A-range AM Best ratings, 24/7 claims reporting, rideshare, gap-type, rental and roadside options, and an app-based usage-based program. The big difference is footprint: Mercury writes in 11 states, principally California; Progressive is national. Neither is "cheaper." Price depends on the driver, so we quote both on identical coverage.
We recently added Mercury Insurance to our lineup alongside Progressive, which we have represented for years. We quote Mercury home and auto in Illinois today, alongside Progressive, and will add other states as Mercury appoints us. So the question at our desk is now: Mercury or Progressive?
This post answers it from each company's own pages, rating-agency releases and investor filings, with a link on every fact. We are paid the same either way, so we have no reason to steer you.
Who Is Each Carrier Built For?
Mercury is a regional specialist. Its FY2025 Form 10-K says it writes "in 11 states, principally California," that private passenger auto was 60.0% of 2025 direct premiums written, and that it sells "through a network of approximately 8,510 independent agents." Its About page dates its formation to 1961, headquartered in Brea, California. If you want a carrier focused on personal auto and home sold through local agents, Mercury fits.
Progressive is the opposite in scale. Its auto page calls it "the largest auto insurer in the nation," citing S&P Global Market Intelligence data for first-quarter 2026. Its 2025 Annual Report shows $83.2 billion in net premiums written and 38.6 million policies in force at year-end 2025, and calls Progressive "the largest seller of motorcycle and boat policies" and "the market leader in commercial auto insurance." If you have a bike, boat, RV or business vehicle alongside your cars, that breadth matters.
Both sell through independent agents, which is why we can quote them side by side. For the backstory, see why we love Progressive and why we added Mercury.
Mercury vs. Progressive: Head-to-Head Comparison
Every fact below links to the carrier page, filing or rating release it came from. Feature availability varies by state for both companies.
| Category | Mercury Insurance | Progressive |
|---|---|---|
| Size, 2025 | $5.72 billion net premiums written (FY2025 results) | $83.2 billion net premiums written; 38.6 million policies in force (2025 Annual Report) |
| AM Best rating | A (Excellent), outlook stable, affirmed Feb. 24, 2026 (AM Best) | A+ (Superior), outlook stable, affirmed May 1, 2026 (AM Best) |
| Where it writes auto | AZ, CA, FL, GA, IL, NV, NJ, NY, OK, TX, VA (Mercury) | State pages for all 50 states (Progressive) |
| Usage-based program | MercuryGO: 5% participation discount (up to 10% for teens), up to 40% off at renewal; 9 states (Mercury) | Snapshot: average $164 sign-up discount, $328 average savings; "not available in CA" (Progressive) |
| Rideshare coverage | Covers Period 1 (app on, no fare accepted) "for as little as $0.90 a day"; 9 states (Mercury) | Endorsement for app-on waiting period plus deductible reimbursement; "may not be available in all states" (Progressive) |
| Gap-type coverage | Gap insurance listed as an optional add-on (Mercury) | Loan/lease payoff, up to 25% of actual cash value (Progressive) |
| Rental reimbursement | "$30 - $100 per day for up to 30 days" (Mercury) | Pays for a substitute vehicle "up to your policy's limits" (Progressive) |
| Roadside assistance | Tow limits of $75, $500 or $1,000; lockout, jump-start, tire change, fuel delivery (Mercury) | Towing, lock-out help, tire changes, fuel or fluid delivery (Progressive) |
| Accident forgiveness | Not listed on the coverage or discount pages we reviewed (Mercury) | Small ($500 or less), Large (5+ years) and a purchasable option (Progressive) |
| Claims reporting | "24 hours a day, seven days a week," online or by phone (Mercury) | "24-hour claims service"; Photo Estimate and guaranteed network-shop repairs (Progressive) |
What Coverage Options Do Mercury and Progressive Offer?
On the core policy, the two are close: Mercury's coverage page and Progressive's coverage page list the same six core coverages. The differences are in the extras.
Rideshare
Mercury's rideshare page covers "Period 1," when your app is on but you have not accepted a fare, can extend to delivery platforms "but exact coverages may vary by state," and lists nine states (not New York or New Jersey). Progressive's rideshare page covers the same waiting period and adds deductible reimbursement: with a $1,000 rideshare-company deductible and a $500 personal deductible, Progressive pays the $500 difference.
Gap, rental and roadside
Mercury lists plain gap insurance as an add-on; Progressive calls its version loan/lease payoff and caps it at 25% of actual cash value. On rental reimbursement, Mercury publishes "$30 - $100 per day for up to 30 days," while Progressive pays "up to your policy's limits." On roadside, Mercury's roadside page publishes tow limits of $75, $500 and $1,000 (roughly 15, 100 and 200 miles); Progressive lists towing, lockout, tire and fuel service without published tiers.
Extras only one carrier publishes
Progressive adds pet injury coverage up to $1,000 with collision, custom parts coverage that "typically has a $5,000 limit," and Deductible Savings Bank, $50 off your deductible for each claim-free, violation-free six-month period. Mercury lists custom equipment coverage and sells a separate Mechanical Protection plan for breakdowns.
Accident forgiveness
This is the clearest gap. Progressive's accident forgiveness page describes Small Accident Forgiveness (rate "stays the same for your first claim that's less than or equal to $500," automatic for new customers in most states), Large Accident Forgiveness after five years accident- and violation-free, and a purchasable option "not available in all states." The Mercury coverage and discount pages we reviewed do not list accident forgiveness. If a forgiven first accident matters to you, ask us what Mercury offers in your state.
MercuryGO vs. Snapshot: How Do the Usage-Based Programs Compare?
MercuryGO scores distracted driving, speeding, acceleration, braking and cornering. Mercury says you "instantly get a 5% Participation Discount," up to 10% for teens, and can "earn up to an additional 40% off at renewal based on how you drive," measured over the latest 91-day period. Its FAQ is explicit: "No, your rate will not go up due to your score or participation in the program." Mercury lists it in nine states; the participation discount "varies by state."
Snapshot runs through the Progressive app or a plug-in device. Progressive says you "get an automatic discount just for signing up," an average of $164, and that customers who renewed and earned the discount "saved an average of $328." The catch: "Your rate may increase with high-risk driving. But, only about 2 out of 10 drivers actually get an increase." Snapshot is "not available in CA," and the participation discount is not available in New York.
Our read: a smooth, low-mileage driver can do well in either. A driver unsure how the app will score them has less downside with MercuryGO, because Mercury says the score cannot raise the rate.
Want both quotes on one page? We compare Mercury, Progressive and 20+ other carriers on identical coverage. Free, no obligation, and the online form takes about three minutes before a licensed agent calls you back. Rated 4.9 stars on Google from 130+ reviews.
Which Discounts Does Each Carrier Advertise?
Mercury's discount page names five: anti-theft, multi-policy, good driver, multi-vehicle and good grades, "subject to qualification requirements and may not be available in all states." It publishes no percentages; the real figure is in the rating plan filed in your state.
Progressive's discount page is longer and publishes some averages: multi-car "average savings of 12%," online quote 7%, sign online 10%, good student "starts at 5%," plus a dozen more (multi-policy, continuous insurance, teen driver, homeowner, pay-in-full and others), each with state footnotes. Its auto page says customers "earn an average of 7 discounts." Progressive's Loyalty Rewards program adds tiered perks but is "not currently available in Hawaii, Alaska, North Carolina, or California."
A longer discount list does not mean a lower premium; discounts come off a base rate that differs by carrier. Our guide to what affects your auto rate explains why.
What Is the Claims Experience Like?
Mercury's claims page says you can file "24 hours a day, seven days a week" online or by phone, and that it offers preferred body shops "if you choose." Progressive's claims page describes reporting by phone or app, a Photo Estimate option ("we'll review your photos and video, then send you an estimate") and a pledge to "guarantee your repairs at network shops for as long as you own or lease your vehicle." Both Mercury's app and Progressive's app handle ID cards, payments and roadside; Progressive's also lets you "report a claim, send photos, and see status updates."
On third-party scores, the J.D. Power 2025 U.S. Auto Claims Satisfaction Study release put overall satisfaction at 700 on a 1,000-point scale and named Erie (743), NJM (731) and Liberty Mutual (730) as the top three. Neither Mercury nor Progressive is named there, nor among regional winners in the 2026 U.S. Auto Insurance Study release, so we will not invent a claims verdict. Either way, as your agent we handle the carrier conversation for you.
How Financially Strong Are Mercury and Progressive?
Both sit in AM Best's "A" range. On February 24, 2026, AM Best affirmed the A (Excellent) rating of the Mercury Casualty Group members and revised the outlook to stable from negative, noting $2.4 billion in policyholder surplus and a 96.3% combined ratio for 2025 despite the January 2025 California wildfires. Mercury's third-quarter 2026 results show nine-month net premiums written of $4.75 billion, up 10.5%.
On May 1, 2026, AM Best affirmed the A+ (Superior) rating of The Progressive Corporation's members with a stable outlook, citing "$11.3 billion in net income" in 2025 versus $8.5 billion in 2024. A+ is one notch above A. Both are secure; the difference is degree, not whether claims get paid.
Where Does Each Carrier Write Auto Insurance?
Mercury's auto page lists Arizona, California, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Nevada, New Jersey, New York, Oklahoma, Texas and Virginia, and its 10-K says California produced 82.1% of 2025 direct premiums written. Progressive publishes car insurance pages for all 50 states, noting coverages "vary by state, and are not available in all states."
For our agency: we quote Mercury home and auto in Illinois today, alongside Progressive, and will add other states as Mercury appoints us. Illinois drivers can start with our Illinois auto insurance requirements guide; homeowners, with our Illinois home insurance page.
Which Is Cheaper, Mercury or Progressive?
We do not know until we quote you, and neither does anyone publishing a ranking. Each company files its own rating plan in each state, and your premium depends on ZIP code, vehicles, drivers, record, prior insurance, credit where allowed, limits, deductibles and discounts. We reached the same conclusion in Progressive vs. GEICO.
How Does an Independent Agent Quote Both Side by Side?
- One intake. Fill out our quick quote form once (about three minutes) or call us.
- Identical specifications. Both quotes get the same limits, deductibles and add-ons, so a lower number means a lower price, not thinner coverage.
- Feature check. We flag where the carriers differ for you: rideshare, a financed car, a teen who could use MercuryGO, a wish for accident forgiveness.
- The rest of the panel. We run the same specs across our other carriers. Sometimes neither wins.
- Your call. We show you the numbers and let you decide. Quotes are free and carry no obligation.
Once you are a client, we review every renewal and re-shop when an increase is out of line.
The Bottom Line
Mercury is the focused regional specialist with a rate-protected usage-based program and clearly published add-on limits; Progressive is the national carrier with the broader menu of extras and the higher AM Best rating. Neither is cheaper by default. To see both prices for your exact coverage, start a free quote or call (847) 908-5665.
Ready to compare Mercury and Progressive? We quote both, plus 20+ other carriers, on identical coverage. Free, no obligation, about three minutes online and a licensed agent calls you back.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Mercury or Progressive cheaper for auto insurance?
Neither carrier is cheaper for everyone. Each company prices by its own rating plan, so the lower quote depends on your state, ZIP code, vehicles, driving record, credit where allowed, coverage limits and discounts. Published averages do not tell you which one wins for your household. We quote Mercury and Progressive with identical limits and deductibles and show you both numbers.
What is the difference between MercuryGO and Progressive Snapshot?
Both are usage-based programs that score how you drive through a phone app. Mercury says MercuryGO gives a 5% participation discount at sign-up (up to 10% for teen drivers) and up to 40% off at renewal, and its FAQ says your rate will not go up because of your score. Progressive says Snapshot customers who renewed and earned the discount saved an average of $328, but that rates may increase with high-risk driving, which it says happens to about 2 out of 10 drivers. Availability and discount amounts vary by state for both programs.
Which states does Mercury Insurance write auto insurance in?
Mercury's auto insurance page lists Arizona, California, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Nevada, New Jersey, New York, Oklahoma, Texas and Virginia. Its FY2025 10-K says the company writes in 11 states, principally California, which produced 82.1% of its 2025 direct premiums written. Better Choice quotes Mercury home and auto in Illinois today and will add other states as Mercury appoints us.
Does Mercury or Progressive offer accident forgiveness?
Progressive publishes three forms: Small Accident Forgiveness for a first claim of $500 or less, available to new customers in most states from day one; Large Accident Forgiveness through Loyalty Rewards for customers with at least five years of tenure who stay accident- and violation-free; and a purchasable Progressive Accident Forgiveness option that is not available in all states. The Mercury auto coverage and discount pages we reviewed do not list an accident forgiveness feature. Ask your agent what applies in your state.
Can an independent agent quote both Mercury and Progressive?
Yes. Better Choice Insurance Group is an independent agency that compares 22+ carriers, and we are appointed with both Mercury and Progressive. One conversation gets you both quotes built on the same limits and deductibles, plus the rest of our panel. Quotes are free and carry no obligation; the online form takes about three minutes and a licensed agent calls you back.
Related Reading
- Why We Added Mercury Insurance to Our Lineup
- Why We Love Progressive
- Progressive vs. GEICO Auto Insurance
- Progressive vs. Safeco Auto Insurance
- What Actually Affects Your Auto Insurance Rate
- Illinois Auto Insurance Requirements
About the author
Evan Larson — Licensed Insurance Agent at Better Choice Insurance Group, an independent insurance agency in St. Charles, Illinois licensed in 14 states.
Last reviewed: November 2026