Quick answer: Mercury Insurance is now one of the carriers Better Choice Insurance Group quotes. It is a 1962-founded, AM Best A (Excellent) rated carrier that writes auto, home, condo, renters, landlord, umbrella and business auto, and it sells only through independent agents like us. It fits households that want one agent-serviced company for the cars and the house. Its main limits are an 11-state footprint and heavy California exposure. We quote Mercury home and auto insurance in Illinois today, and will add other states as Mercury appoints us there.
Every carrier we add to our panel earns its spot the same way: financial strength, claims handling, product lineup, and whether the company is built to work with an independent agent. Mercury Insurance checks those boxes a little differently from the rest of our lineup, and that difference is why we are glad to have it.
Better Choice Insurance Group is appointed with Mercury for both home and auto. Here is who Mercury is, who it fits, where it falls short, and how we quote it alongside the other 22+ carriers we represent.
Who Is Mercury Insurance?
Mercury is the consumer brand of Mercury General Corporation, a publicly traded insurance holding company (NYSE: MCY). According to Mercury’s About page, the company was formed in 1961, is headquartered in Brea, California, employs more than 4,300 people, holds over $9.6 billion in total assets, and sells its products “through a network of local, independent agents” in 11 states.
The company’s own founder page says it sold its first policy on April 1, 1962, and operated exclusively in California until 1990. Founder George Joseph named it Mercury because, in his words, “I wanted us to be fast and nimble.” Joseph died on August 26, 2026, at age 104; Mercury’s announcement says the board appointed Gabriel Tirador, CEO since 2007, as Chairman, with Joseph’s son Victor continuing as President and Chief Operating Officer.
Mercury is not small. Its third-quarter 2026 results report 1,085,000 personal auto policies and 968,000 homeowners policies in force as of September 30, 2026, with net premiums written of $1.64 billion for the quarter, up 9.2% from a year earlier.
Who Does Mercury Fit Best?
Based on Mercury’s own product pages, here is where we expect Mercury to be worth a close look:
- Households that want auto and home with one company. Mercury’s auto page lists a multi-policy discount for bundling auto with home or renters, and its homeowners page lists the same discount from the other direction. If you have been piecing together an auto-only carrier with a separate home carrier, Mercury gives us a bundled option to price against that combination.
- Drivers with a clean record, several cars, or a student. Mercury’s auto discounts are good driver, multi-vehicle, good grades for young drivers, and anti-theft. Mercury notes that discounts are “subject to qualification requirements and may not be available in all states.”
- Homeowners who have invested in their house. Mercury’s homeowners page lists discounts for protective devices, fire-resistant construction materials, newer homes, gated communities and higher deductibles, and its standard coverage menu includes extended replacement cost up to 150% of the dwelling limit, identity theft protection, and guest medical protection.
- Condo owners and renters. Mercury’s condo page includes improvements coverage, loss assessment and coverage for a condo you rent to others; its renters page offers an optional roommate endorsement.
- Landlords. Mercury’s landlord page lists fair rental value, premises liability, service line protection and home systems protection, with a discount for pairing landlord coverage with an auto or homeowners policy.
- People who need a larger umbrella. Mercury’s umbrella page says limits run from $1 million to $5 million in California, Texas, Oklahoma and Illinois, and $1 million to $2 million in other states where umbrella is available.
- Small businesses with vehicles. Mercury’s business auto page covers passenger vehicles, vans, pickups, SUVs, flatbeds, box trucks and utility trucks for contractors, caterers, retailers, offices and similar businesses.
Mercury also sells a separate mechanical breakdown plan, Mercury Mechanical Protection, offered since 1974 for new and pre-owned vehicles.
What Makes Mercury Different From Our Other Carriers?
Distribution. Several of the auto carriers on our panel were built as direct-to-consumer companies that also work with agents; you can buy them online or through a call center, and the agent is one channel among several. Mercury’s model is the opposite. Its agent page describes independent agents as “front-line underwriters, public relations representatives, and the face of Mercury to their local community,” and the company credits those agency relationships with helping it become “one of the fastest growing insurers in the nation.” A June 2026 Mercury release counts more than 6,340 independent agents in 11 states.
Why does that matter to you? When a carrier is built around agents, the agent is expected to have the underwriting conversation up front, explain the coverage, and stay in the loop on service and claims. That is the role we play for our clients, and it is why we wrote about independent vs. captive agents: a captive agent can only sell one company, and a direct carrier skips the agent altogether. With Mercury, you get a carrier that wants an agent in the picture, and an agent who is not tied to that carrier.
The second difference is breadth. A couple of our most competitive auto carriers write auto only, which is fine when we pair them with a separate home carrier. Mercury writes auto, home, condo, renters, landlord, umbrella and business auto under one roof. That does not automatically make Mercury cheaper; it makes Mercury a complete alternative we can price against any combination. If you want to see how two of the biggest direct carriers compare on auto alone, our Progressive vs. GEICO comparison is a good companion to this post.
How Does Mercury Handle Claims and Service?
Here is what Mercury publishes about its own process, from its claims page:
- Claims can be filed online or by phone at (800) 503-3724, “24 hours a day, seven days a week.”
- A customer service representative gathers details about the incident, reviews the coverage that applies, and can help you choose a body shop, arrange a tow from the scene, or set up a rental car.
- Mercury says it guarantees repairs completed by a Mercury authorized repair shop “for as long as you own the car.”
Day-to-day service is built around the Mercury app, which Mercury says is free and lets you view digital ID cards (and save them to Apple or Google Wallet), make one-time or automatic payments, add or remove vehicles and drivers, request roadside assistance, go paperless, and reach your agent or the claims line with one tap. Mercury’s payment page also lists phone, mail and MoneyGram cash payment options.
What we cannot tell you yet is how Mercury’s claims service compares statistically. Review sites quote J.D. Power figures for Mercury, but we could not confirm them from J.D. Power’s own published study, so we leave them out. For independent complaint data on the specific Mercury company quoting you, the NAIC Consumer Information Source lets you look up any insurer by name.
Is Mercury Financially Strong?
Yes, by the measure that matters most to us. On February 24, 2026, AM Best affirmed the Financial Strength Rating of A (Excellent) and the Long-Term Issuer Credit Rating of “a” (Excellent) for the members of Mercury Casualty Group, and revised its outlook to stable from negative. AM Best called Mercury’s balance sheet strength “very strong,” citing policyholder surplus of $2.4 billion at December 31, 2025, up $362 million year over year, and a 2025 combined ratio of 96.3%.
That matters because 2025 was the year of the Palisades and Eaton wildfires in Los Angeles County. AM Best’s release puts Mercury’s net wildfire losses at $380 million against $2.2 billion gross, after reinsurance and an estimated $538 million in Eaton fire subrogation. Mercury’s CEO has said the company managed more than 2,900 wildfire claims and paid more than $1.4 billion to policyholders, as reported by Insurance Business. A carrier that absorbed that and finished the year with a combined ratio under 100% is one we are comfortable putting in front of clients.
What Are Mercury’s Honest Limitations?
- It is an 11-state carrier. Mercury’s auto page lists Arizona, California, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Nevada, New Jersey, New York, Oklahoma, Texas and Virginia. Its homeowners and condo pages list the same states except Florida. Several of the 14 states where we are licensed are not on Mercury’s list, and our own appointment currently covers Illinois.
- California still drives its results. Mercury was California-only for its first 28 years and remains heavily exposed there. AM Best moved Mercury’s outlook to negative in February 2025 after the wildfires before restoring it to stable in 2026, and Mercury’s third-quarter 2026 report still shows adverse reserve development on the Palisades and Eaton fires. Insurance Business reports Mercury received a 6.9% California homeowners rate increase effective July 2026.
- Features vary by state. Almost every Mercury product page carries the note that coverages and discounts “may vary by state” or “may not be available in all states.” The umbrella limits above $2 million, for example, are listed only for California, Texas, Oklahoma and Illinois. Read your quote, not the brochure.
- Agent-serviced means agent-serviced. If you want to buy a policy entirely online and never talk to a person, Mercury’s model is not designed for that. We think that is a strength, but it is a real difference.
Mercury at a Glance
| Fact | Detail | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Founded | Formed 1961; first policy sold April 1, 1962 | Mercury About and founder pages |
| Ownership | Mercury General Corporation, NYSE: MCY | Mercury press releases |
| Financial strength | AM Best A (Excellent), stable outlook, affirmed Feb. 24, 2026 | AM Best via Business Wire |
| Policyholder surplus | $2.4 billion at Dec. 31, 2025 | AM Best |
| Policies in force | 1,085,000 auto; 968,000 homeowners (Sept. 30, 2026) | Mercury Q3 2026 results |
| Distribution | Independent agents; 6,340+ in 11 states | Mercury, June 2026 |
| Products | Auto, home, condo, renters, landlord, umbrella, business auto, mechanical protection | Mercury product pages |
| Claims line | (800) 503-3724, 24/7 | Mercury claims page |
| Where we quote it | Illinois today; other states as Mercury appoints us | Better Choice Insurance Group |
How Do We Quote Mercury Alongside 22+ Carriers?
Exactly the same way we quote everyone else, which is the point of being independent. You send us your current declarations pages, or fill out our quick quote form, which takes about three minutes, and a licensed agent calls you back. We match your coverage line by line (liability limits, deductibles, replacement cost provisions, endorsements) and run it across our carrier panel. Mercury is now one of the carriers in that run for Illinois auto and home, and it will be added in other states as Mercury appoints us there.
Then we show you the results side by side. Sometimes Mercury wins on the bundle, sometimes an auto-only carrier plus a separate home carrier beats it, and sometimes your current carrier is already the best value. We will tell you which. To understand why quotes come back so different, see our guide to what affects your auto insurance rate walks through the factors every carrier weighs differently.
For our existing clients, nothing changes about how we work: we review every renewal and re-shop when an increase is out of line. Mercury simply gives us one more strong place to look.
The Bottom Line
We love Mercury for three reasons. It is a financially strong, 60-plus-year carrier that came through a historic catastrophe year with its AM Best A rating intact. It writes the whole household, cars to house to umbrella, so it stands on its own against any bundle. And it is built around independent agents, which means it expects us to do our job.
Mercury is not available everywhere, and it will not be the lowest quote for everyone. But if you live in Illinois and have not had a bundled quote from an agent-based carrier lately, it is worth seeing where Mercury lands. Visit our Mercury carrier page for quick links to claims, payments and the app, or browse all of our carriers.
Want to see Mercury next to the rest of the market? We compare your exact coverage across 22+ carriers, Mercury included where available. Free, no obligation, about three minutes to start. Rated 4.9 stars on Google from 130+ reviews.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Mercury Insurance a good company?
Mercury has written insurance since 1962 and its insurance subsidiaries carry an AM Best Financial Strength Rating of A (Excellent), affirmed on February 24, 2026 with a stable outlook. It is a publicly traded company (NYSE: MCY) with $2.4 billion in policyholder surplus at the end of 2025, according to AM Best. Whether it is a good company for you depends on price and coverage for your specific household, which is why we quote it next to our other carriers rather than on its own.
Does Mercury sell insurance through independent agents?
Yes. Mercury says its products are sold through a network of local, independent agents, and a June 2026 Mercury release counts more than 6,340 independent agents in 11 states. Better Choice Insurance Group is appointed with Mercury for both home and auto. We quote Mercury home and auto insurance in Illinois today, and will add other states as Mercury appoints us there.
What does Mercury Insurance cover?
Mercury writes personal auto, homeowners, condo, renters, landlord and umbrella insurance, plus business auto and a mechanical breakdown plan it calls Mercury Mechanical Protection. Its auto page lists liability, collision, comprehensive, uninsured/underinsured motorist, medical, ride-hailing coverage, roadside assistance and rental reimbursement. Mercury notes that coverages and discounts may vary by state and may not be available in all states.
What discounts does Mercury offer?
Mercury's auto page lists anti-theft, multi-policy, good driver, multi-vehicle and good grades discounts. Its homeowners page lists multi-policy, protective devices, fire-resistant construction, newer home, gated community and higher-deductible discounts. Mercury states that discounts are subject to qualification requirements and may not be available in all states, so the discounts on your actual quote are the ones that count.
How do I file a claim with Mercury?
Mercury says claims can be filed online or by phone at (800) 503-3724, 24 hours a day, seven days a week. A representative gathers the details, reviews your coverage, and can arrange a tow or rental and help you choose a repair shop. Mercury guarantees repairs completed at a Mercury authorized repair shop for as long as you own the car. As your agent, we can also help you start and track a claim; call us at (847) 908-5665.
How does Better Choice quote Mercury?
The same way we quote every carrier. You give us your current declarations pages or fill out our short online form, which takes about three minutes, and a licensed agent calls back. We run the same coverage across 22+ carriers, Mercury included where it is available for your address, and show you the results side by side. Quotes are free with no obligation, and for our own clients we review every renewal and re-shop when an increase is out of line.
Related Reading
- Mercury Insurance Review (2026): Carrier Profile & Quick Links
- Progressive vs. GEICO Auto Insurance
- What Affects Your Auto Insurance Rate
- Is Bundling Home and Auto Insurance Worth It?
- Benefits of Using an Independent Agent
About the author
Evan Larson — Licensed Insurance Agent at Better Choice Insurance Group, an independent insurance agency in St. Charles, Illinois licensed in 14 states.
Last reviewed: November 2026