Mon–Fri: 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
(847) 908-5665  |  [email protected]

Best Home Insurance in Dallas–Fort Worth (2026): How to Compare

November 2026  |  10 min read  |  By Evan Larson, Licensed Insurance Agent
Written and reviewed by Evan Larson, Licensed Insurance Agent  ·  Updated November 2026

Quick answer: No company is best for every Dallas–Fort Worth home. TDI county data shows 2025 average premiums of $3,939 (Tarrant) to $4,363 (Dallas), all above the $3,489 statewide average (preliminary), and wind and hail caused 61% of the four counties' homeowners paid losses from 2019 to 2025. So compare the wind/hail deductible in dollars and the roof terms first. On TDI's statewide complaint data, Texas Farm Bureau, Progressive, Farmers and Travelers ranked highest.

This guide starts with what the Texas Department of Insurance (TDI) publishes for Dallas, Tarrant, Collin and Denton counties: what homeowners paid in 2025 and what damaged their homes from 2019 through 2025. Then it ranks companies on TDI's complaint data, which is statewide. We're an independent agency, so we mark which companies we quote and leave the rest where the data puts them.

How Much Is Home Insurance in Dallas–Fort Worth?

More than the Texas average. TDI's homeowners market overview puts the statewide 2025 average premium at $3,489 (preliminary). Its county map data shows all four DFW counties above that:

CountyAvg. premium, 2025vs. $3,489 statewideAvg. premium, 2024Avg. insured amount, 2025FAIR Plan policies
Dallas$4,363+25%$4,058$512,0003,012
Collin$4,343+24%$4,105$569,000405
Denton$4,336+24%$4,045$543,000780
Tarrant$3,939+13%$3,692$453,0002,346

TDI's county map reports the average premium for homeowners policies that include wind coverage; the $3,489 statewide figure is TDI's overall 2025 preliminary average, so treat the comparison as close, not exact. Weighting TDI's 2025 county figures by policy count gives about $3,533 statewide for policies with wind (our calculation). County figures from TDI's county premium map data.

Three things stand out. Dallas, Collin and Denton are within $30 of each other, even though Collin's average insured amount is $57,000 higher than Dallas County's. Tarrant is about $400 lower. And Dallas County's average nearly doubled from $2,207 in 2019, per the same TDI data. Weighted by policy count, the four counties averaged about $4,221 in 2025 across roughly 1.33 million policies with wind coverage (our calculation).

TDI counts 115 to 117 companies collecting homeowners premium in each county. City detail is on our Dallas, Fort Worth and Tarrant County pages.

What Damages DFW Homes Most?

Wind and hail, by a wide margin. TDI's homeowners losses by county data covers paid claims from 2019 through 2025:

CountyWind/hail share of paid losses, 2019–25Water shareWind/hail paid per policy, 2025Worst wind/hail year per policy
Dallas54%30%$8852019: $1,994
Tarrant63%23%$1,4202021: $1,880
Collin64%26%$2,2472023: $2,896
Denton65%24%$1,2942024: $3,190
All Texas counties61%23%$1,010–

Source: TDI homeowners losses by county, 2019–2025 paid losses; shares and per-policy averages are our calculations. TDI's county file has four loss types (wind, water, fire, other) and no separate hail line; its 2021 statewide wind total equals TDI's separately published statewide wind plus hail figures, so we read "wind" as wind and hail. Flood isn't in these numbers: TDI notes most home policies don't cover flood. TWIA wind losses are excluded.

Across the four counties, insurers paid about $12.1 billion in wind and hail losses over seven years, roughly $1,316 per policy per year, against about $900 statewide (our calculation). Collin County's 2025 wind/hail payout alone was $623 million, and Denton's 2024 figure was $748 million.

The worst year moves around the metro, so a neighbor's renewal is a poor guide to yours. The one year water beat wind was 2021: Dallas County water losses hit $608 million, more than double its wind total. That was the year of the February 11–19 freeze, which TDI's winter weather report ties to "freezing pipes" and related water damage.

What Does That Mean for Your Wind and Hail Deductible?

In DFW, the wind/hail deductible is often the number that decides what a claim pays. TDI's deductibles guide uses a home insured for $150,000: a 5% deductible is $7,500, so a $6,500 hail repair pays nothing. TDI adds that a home deductible applies to each claim.

At DFW insured values the dollars are larger. If your home were insured near Dallas County's average of $512,000, a 1% deductible would be $5,120 and a 2% deductible $10,240. Near Collin's $569,000 average, those become $5,690 and $11,380 (our arithmetic). Two quotes that differ by a few hundred dollars a year may differ by several thousand on a claim.

Ask whether wind/hail has its own deductible, price two deductible levels with each carrier, and see our Texas wind/hail deductible explainer.

Why Do Roof Terms Matter So Much in DFW?

Because roofs are where hail claims land. TDI warns that "as roofs age, some companies will switch to actual cash value," which pays less for an older roof, and tells homeowners to check roof coverage at every renewal. Ask each carrier whether it uses a roof payment schedule and at what age it changes.

TDI also says companies "often offer discounts for roofs made of materials that help prevent roof damage," per its discount guide. If you're replacing a hail-damaged roof, ask about impact-resistant materials and see our FORTIFIED roof discount guide and ACV vs. replacement cost on roof claims. Fort Worth owners can also read our Fort Worth home insurance page.

Do DFW Homeowners Need Flood Insurance?

Consider it. TDI's flood guide says most home insurance policies don't cover flood damage, that Flash Flood Alley "extends through Central and North Texas," and that on average 40% of NFIP claims occur outside high-risk flood areas. NFIP coverage goes up to $250,000 for the home and $100,000 for belongings, and most flood policies have a 30-day wait.

Flood losses don't appear in the county loss table above because homeowners policies don't pay them. For the Trinity River levees, the August 2022 Dallas flood and Tarrant County creeks, read flood insurance in Dallas–Fort Worth.

Which Home Insurance Companies Rank Best?

TDI publishes complaint figures statewide, not by county, so this is the same table as our statewide Texas ranking, not a Dallas–Fort Worth measurement. It ranks the largest groups on confirmed complaints per policy for 2024 and 2025 combined, from TDI's 2025 Market Conditions Annual Report.

RankInsurance groupDo we quote it?TX market share, 2025Complaints per 10,000 policies, 2024–25
Our calc. from TDI
1Texas Farm BureauNot through us2.44%0.56
2Progressive (ASI)Yes2.39%0.61
3FarmersNot through us8.15%0.80
4TravelersYes5.15%0.92
5State FarmNo (captive)19.10%1.37
6USAANot through us11.22%1.44
7AllstateNo (captive)16.79%1.46
8Iron Family HoldingsNot through us2.38%1.59
9Liberty MutualYes6.05%1.81
10American FamilyNot through us3.98%1.82
11NationwideYes1.36%2.66

All Texas homeowners insurers: 1.34 confirmed complaints per 10,000 policies in 2025 and 1.37 in 2024 (TDI). Every AM Best rating we could verify was A (Excellent) or higher; details are in the statewide guide. Small groups' rates swing more year to year.

Which Carriers Can We Quote in Dallas–Fort Worth?

We represent Travelers, Progressive, Liberty Mutual and Nationwide, plus the rest of a 22+ carrier panel. Three of the panel's home carriers list Texas on their own sites:

All are subject to eligibility for the address. None is in the table above; check them in TDI's complaint index data set. We also quote GEICO, for auto only.

State Farm sells only through its own agents; we can't quote it, but we can quote the carriers above against your current State Farm policy. Allstate is also a captive carrier, and the same applies. We don't quote Farmers, USAA or Texas Farm Bureau either, and on the data Texas Farm Bureau and Farmers ranked above most of our carriers. See independent vs. captive agents and switching from State Farm.

How Do I Get Dallas–Fort Worth Quotes Side by Side?

We quote Travelers, Progressive, Liberty Mutual, Nationwide and our other Texas home carriers side by side with one form, on the same dwelling limit, wind/hail deductible in dollars and roof terms, subject to each carrier's eligibility for the address. The online quick quote takes about three minutes and a licensed agent calls you back; quotes are free and no obligation. If your current policy is the better value, we'll say so. For clients, we review every renewal and re-shop when an increase is out of line. Call (847) 908-5665 (Mon–Fri, 9 AM–6 PM), or start a full quote.

Want your DFW home compared on identical coverage? Send us your declarations page and we'll match the dwelling limit, wind/hail deductible and roof terms across the carriers we represent. Free, no obligation; the online form takes about three minutes. Rated 4.9 stars on Google from 130+ reviews.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best home insurance company in Dallas–Fort Worth?

No single company is best for every Dallas–Fort Worth home, because carriers price roof age, construction, deductibles and claims history differently. Texas Department of Insurance complaint data is published statewide, not by county; on that data, Texas Farm Bureau, Progressive, Farmers and Travelers had the lowest confirmed-complaint rates among the largest Texas home insurers for 2024 and 2025. In DFW, compare the wind and hail deductible in dollars and the roof terms before you compare company names.

How much is homeowners insurance in Dallas–Fort Worth?

Texas Department of Insurance county data shows 2025 average premiums for policies with wind coverage of $4,363 in Dallas County, $4,343 in Collin, $4,336 in Denton and $3,939 in Tarrant. The statewide 2025 average is $3,489 (preliminary). Your own premium depends on your dwelling limit, roof, deductibles and claims history.

Why is home insurance higher in Dallas–Fort Worth than the Texas average?

Wind and hail are the main reason. In TDI's county loss data, wind (which in that file includes hail) made up 61% of homeowners paid losses in Dallas, Tarrant, Collin and Denton counties from 2019 through 2025, averaging about $1,316 per policy per year against about $900 statewide, by our calculation. DFW homes also carry higher average insured amounts, from $453,000 in Tarrant to $569,000 in Collin.

What wind and hail deductible should I choose in Dallas–Fort Worth?

Pick the largest deductible you could pay in cash after a hailstorm, and convert any percentage to dollars first. On a home insured for $512,000, about the Dallas County average, a 1% deductible is $5,120 and a 2% deductible is $10,240. The Texas Department of Insurance notes that a deductible applies to each claim, so a home hit twice pays it twice.

Do I need flood insurance in Dallas–Fort Worth?

Consider it even outside a mapped flood zone. The Texas Department of Insurance says most home insurance policies don't cover flood damage, that Flash Flood Alley extends through Central and North Texas, and that on average 40% of National Flood Insurance Program claims come from outside high-risk areas. Most flood policies have a 30-day waiting period.

Can Better Choice quote State Farm or Allstate in Dallas–Fort Worth?

No. State Farm and Allstate sell through their own captive agents, so we can't quote them. We can quote Travelers, Progressive, Liberty Mutual, Nationwide and our other Texas home carriers, subject to eligibility for the address, against your current State Farm or Allstate declarations page so you compare identical coverage.

Sources

  • Texas Department of Insurance — Texas homeowners insurance market overview ($3,489 2025 preliminary average; county map definitions; FAIR and TWIA): tdi.texas.gov
  • Texas Department of Insurance — county average premium map data, 2019–2025 (Texas Statistical Plan for Residential Risks; Tableau Public data export): public.tableau.com
  • Texas Department of Insurance — Texas homeowners losses by county (updated June 22, 2026): tdi.texas.gov; data file: home-owners-losses-by-county-25.csv
  • Texas Department of Insurance — 2025 Market Conditions Annual Report (market share and complaint tables): tdi.texas.gov (PDF)
  • Texas Department of Insurance — Complaint indexes and policy counts (Texas Open Data Portal): data.texas.gov
  • Texas Department of Insurance — What to know about deductibles: tdi.texas.gov
  • Texas Department of Insurance — Insurance and your roof: tdi.texas.gov
  • Texas Department of Insurance — Lower your home insurance cost by asking for discounts: tdi.texas.gov
  • Texas Department of Insurance — Flood insurance: Why you need a policy: tdi.texas.gov
  • Texas Department of Insurance — Insured Losses Resulting from the February 2021 Texas Winter Weather Event (Nov. 2022): tdi.texas.gov (PDF)
  • Bamboo Insurance — Texas Essential Homeowner Program announcement, Sept. 4, 2026: bambooinsurance.com
  • Orion180 — Texas: orion180.com
  • Hippo — Homeowners insurance in Texas: hippo.com

Related Reading

About the author

Evan Larson — Licensed Insurance Agent at Better Choice Insurance Group, an independent insurance agency in St. Charles, Illinois licensed in 14 states.

Last reviewed: November 2026

Compare DFW Home Insurance on Your Roof and Deductible

We quote identical coverage, wind/hail deductibles and roof terms across the carriers we represent and tell you honestly where your current policy stands.

Get Your Free Quote