Mon–Fri: 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
(847) 908-5665  |  [email protected]

Best Home Insurance Companies in Texas (2026): How to Compare

November 2026  |  11 min read  |  By Evan Larson, Licensed Insurance Agent
Written and reviewed by Evan Larson, Licensed Insurance Agent  ·  Updated November 2026

Quick answer: No company is best for every Texas home, so we ranked the largest Texas home insurers on public data instead. Using the Texas Department of Insurance's 2024 and 2025 confirmed-complaint rates, with AM Best financial strength as a gate, Texas Farm Bureau, Progressive, Farmers and Travelers ranked highest; State Farm, the largest writer, ranked fifth. TDI puts the 2025 average premium at $3,489 (preliminary). Compare wind/hail deductibles and roof terms in dollars before price.

Texas homeowners pay some of the highest premiums in the country, and the "best company" lists online rarely show where their scores come from. This guide uses only public data: market share and complaint counts from the Texas Department of Insurance (TDI), financial strength from AM Best, and J.D. Power only where its press release states a result. Where a figure isn't published, the table says so.

We're an independent agency with an office in San Antonio, so we have a stake. We've marked which companies we quote and ranked the ones we don't sell exactly where the data puts them.

How Did We Rank Texas Home Insurance Companies?

  1. Who's included. The ten largest insurance groups by 2025 Texas homeowners premium in TDI's 2025 Market Conditions Annual Report (published March 2026), plus Nationwide, a carrier we quote that ranks 13th.
  2. Financial strength gate. AM Best's Financial Strength Rating and the date of the latest action we could verify. Every rating we verified is A (Excellent) or higher.
  3. Rank order: complaints. The same TDI report lists confirmed complaints and policies written for the top 25 homeowners groups in 2025 and 2024. We converted TDI's "percent of complaints per policy" to complaints per 10,000 policies and ranked on the two years combined, lowest first (our calculation from TDI's counts).
  4. Price is not ranked. It depends on the house, and we'd be guessing.

Not published means we couldn't find the figure in a public primary source we were able to access and verify for this article; we ranked on the data that exists rather than estimating.

Best Home Insurance Companies in Texas: The Ranked Table

Rank Insurance group (TDI name) Do we quote it? TX homeowners market share, 2025
Source: TDI
Confirmed complaints per 10,000 policies, 2025 / 2024
Source: TDI
Two-year rate
Our calc. from TDI
AM Best FSR (action date)
Source: AM Best releases
1Texas Farm Bureau Mutual GroupNot through us2.44%0.45 / 0.660.56not published
2Progressive Group (ASI)Yes2.39%0.64 / 0.570.61not published
3Farmers Insurance GroupNot through us8.15%0.41 / 1.240.80not published
4Travelers GroupYes5.15%0.97 / 0.880.92A++ (affirmed Aug. 8, 2025)
5State Farm GroupNot through us (captive)19.10%1.49 / 1.251.37A for State Farm Lloyds (affirmed Nov. 14, 2025)
6United Services Automobile Assoc. GroupNot through us11.22%1.89 / 0.961.44A++ (affirmed July 2, 2025)
7Allstate Insurance GroupNot through us (captive)16.79%1.34 / 1.581.46A+ (affirmed Sept. 2, 2026)
8Iron Family Holdings GroupNot through us2.38%1.73 / 1.451.59not published
9Liberty Mutual GroupYes6.05%2.13 / 1.551.81A (stable, per Liberty Mutual)
10American Family Insurance GroupNot through us3.98%1.78 / 1.871.82A for American Family Mutual and core affiliates (affirmed Sept. 24, 2025)
11Nationwide Corporation GroupYes1.36%1.98 / 3.162.66A, positive outlook (Nov. 2026)

All Texas homeowners insurers: 1.34 confirmed complaints per 10,000 policies in 2025 (1,107 complaints on 8,233,096 policies) and 1.37 in 2024. Small counts swing these rates: Texas Farm Bureau had 8 and 13 confirmed complaints in the two years, Nationwide 14 and 31. Progressive's Texas homeowners business includes ASI Lloyds, which TDI calls "a Progressive company"; we could not verify an AM Best rating for that company specifically. AM Best sources are listed at the end of this article.

What Does the Ranking Tell You?

Size and complaint record are different things. The three largest groups, State Farm, Allstate and USAA, together write about 47% of Texas homeowners premium and all land in the middle of the table, close to the statewide rate. Smaller groups took the top two spots.

One year can mislead. Farmers had the lowest 2025 rate in the table but was near the market average in 2024. USAA went the other direction. That's why we used two years.

Our own carriers are spread out. Progressive and Travelers ranked in the top four; Liberty Mutual and Nationwide ranked ninth and eleventh. We'd rather show you that than hide it. A complaint rate is a flag to ask about, not a reason to rule a company in or out on its own.

What Does TDI's 2025 Market Data Say?

TDI's homeowners market overview gives the statewide picture:

  • $3,489 average annual homeowners premium in 2025 (preliminary), across 8,233,096 active policies. See our Texas home insurance page for what drives it.
  • $19.75 billion in direct written premium, from 157 companies in 81 groups.
  • A homeowners combined ratio of 76.8% in 2025, after 98.3% in 2024 and 141.8% in 2021, per TDI's annual statement table. Below 100 means insurers collected more premium than they paid in losses and expenses.
  • Filed homeowners rate requests averaged −4.0% for August through October 2026.

On October 8, 2026, TDI said most homeowners insurers filing since July 1 proposed decreases, affecting about 700,000 policyholders, with filed changes averaging a 4.3% decrease over 90 days. Its examples included ASI Lloyds (a Progressive company) at 6% and Texas Farm Bureau Mutual at 5.2%. Commissioner Amanda Crawford urged Texans to "shop around, and make sure they're getting the best value for their coverage."

Why Can the Wind and Hail Deductible Matter More Than the Company?

Many Texas policies use a percentage deductible for wind and hail, figured from the home's insured value rather than the claim. TDI's deductibles guide uses a home insured for $150,000: a 5% deductible is $7,500, so a $6,500 hail repair pays nothing, while a policy with a $500 deductible pays $6,000.

Two quotes from two "top-ranked" companies aren't comparable if one has a 1% wind/hail deductible and the other 2%. Convert every percentage to dollars first. Our Texas wind/hail deductible explainer walks through the math.

How Do Roof Schedules and Actual Cash Value Change a Claim?

TDI's replacement cost vs. actual cash value guide shows why the roof terms may be the most important line in a Texas policy. Its example: a $200,000 home with a 2% ($4,000) deductible and a $10,000 roof replacement.

Roof ageReplacement cost policy paysActual cash value policy pays
5 years$6,000$4,500
10 years$6,000$3,000
20 years$6,000$0

Source: Texas Department of Insurance example figures.

TDI also warns that "as roofs age, some companies will switch to actual cash value," so check roof coverage at every renewal. Ask each carrier whether it uses a roof payment schedule and at what age it changes. Related: ACV vs. replacement cost on roof claims, FORTIFIED roof discounts in Texas, and aerial imagery and roof non-renewals.

Where Does J.D. Power Fit?

J.D. Power's 2026 U.S. Home Insurance Study (September 15, 2026; 17,191 homeowners and renters) is national, not Texas-specific. In the homeowners segment, Amica ranked highest at 680, followed by Erie Insurance at 678 and Chubb at 676. Amica and Chubb appear in TDI's top 25 Texas homeowners groups at 0.82% and 1.97% market share; neither made our top-10 cut, and the release publishes no scores for the groups in our table.

Which Carriers Do We Quote, and Which Can't We?

We represent Travelers, Progressive, Liberty Mutual and Nationwide, plus the rest of a 22+ carrier panel. Appetite and eligibility vary by address, roof and claims history, so not every carrier will quote every home. Head-to-head reading: Travelers vs. Nationwide, Travelers vs. Safeco, State Farm vs. Travelers and Allstate vs. Travelers.

State Farm and Allstate are captive carriers. State Farm sells only through its own agents; we can't quote it, but we can quote the carriers above against your current State Farm policy, and the same goes for Allstate. Other groups marked "not through us" aren't carriers we quote here; several outranked ours on complaints. See independent vs. captive agents and switching from State Farm.

What If No Company Will Write My Texas Home?

TDI's market overview lists two backstops. The Texas FAIR Plan Association covers homeowners who have been turned down by two insurance companies. The Texas Windstorm Insurance Association sells wind and hail coverage in 14 coastal counties and parts of Harris County east of Highway 146 for residents turned down by an insurer. If you've been dropped, start with what to do when your insurer drops you.

How Do I Check a Texas Insurer Myself?

  1. Find the company name on your declarations page, not just the brand.
  2. Look it up in TDI's complaint index data set, linked from TDI's complaint data page. TDI's index averages 1.00; below 1 means fewer complaints than average for its size.
  3. Check the NAIC Consumer Insurance Search for a national view.
  4. Confirm the current AM Best rating; ratings move, as State Farm's November 2025 action shows.

Get Them Quoted Side by Side

We quote Travelers, Progressive, Liberty Mutual and Nationwide side by side with one form, on the same dwelling limit, deductibles and roof terms, subject to each carrier's eligibility for the address. The online quick quote takes about three minutes and a licensed agent calls you back; quotes are free and no obligation. If your current carrier is still the best value, we'll say so. For clients, we review every renewal and re-shop when an increase is out of line. Call (847) 908-5665 (Mon–Fri, 9 AM–6 PM), visit our San Antonio office at 106 S Saint Marys St, Suite 265, or start a full quote.

Want your Texas home compared on identical coverage? Send us your declarations page and we'll match the dwelling limit, wind/hail deductible and roof terms across the carriers we represent. Free, no obligation; the online form takes about three minutes. Rated 4.9 stars on Google from 130+ reviews.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best home insurance company in Texas?

No single company is best for every Texas home, because carriers price roof age, construction, location, deductibles and claims history differently. On the public data we used, Texas Farm Bureau Mutual Group, Progressive Group, Farmers Insurance Group and Travelers Group had the lowest rates of confirmed complaints per policy among the largest Texas home insurers in the Texas Department of Insurance's 2024 and 2025 figures. Complaint data is a service signal, not a price verdict, so compare identical coverage before choosing.

How much is homeowners insurance in Texas?

The Texas Department of Insurance reports an average annual homeowners premium of $3,489 for 2025, a preliminary figure. Your own premium depends on your dwelling limit, roof age and material, wind and hail deductible, claims history, construction and location, so it can land well above or below that average.

Who is the largest home insurance company in Texas?

State Farm. In the Texas Department of Insurance's 2025 Market Conditions Annual Report, State Farm Group wrote 19.10% of Texas homeowners premium in 2025, followed by Allstate Insurance Group at 16.79% and United Services Automobile Association Group at 11.22%. Market share measures size, not price or service quality.

How does a percentage wind and hail deductible work in Texas?

A percentage deductible is figured from your home's insured value, not the claim. The Texas Department of Insurance's example uses a home insured for $150,000: a 5% deductible is $7,500, so a $6,500 hail repair to the roof would pay nothing, while a policy with a $500 deductible would pay $6,000. Always convert the percentage to dollars before you compare quotes.

Are Texas home insurance rates going down?

Some are. On October 8, 2026, the Texas Department of Insurance said most homeowners insurers that filed rate changes since July 1 proposed decreases, affecting about 700,000 policyholders, and that filed homeowners rate changes averaged a 4.3% decrease over the prior 90 days. Your own renewal can still move differently, so compare the dollars on your declarations page.

Can Better Choice quote State Farm or Allstate in Texas?

No. State Farm and Allstate sell through their own captive agents, so we cannot quote them. We can quote carriers we represent, including Travelers, Progressive, Liberty Mutual and Nationwide, subject to each carrier's eligibility for the address, against your current State Farm or Allstate declarations page so you can compare identical coverage.

Sources

  • Texas Department of Insurance — Texas homeowners insurance market overview: tdi.texas.gov
  • Texas Department of Insurance — 2025 Market Conditions Annual Report (March 2026; market share and complaint tables): tdi.texas.gov (PDF)
  • Texas Department of Insurance — "Home and auto insurance rates trending down for many Texans," Oct. 8, 2026: tdi.texas.gov
  • Texas Department of Insurance — What to know about deductibles: tdi.texas.gov
  • Texas Department of Insurance — Home policies: replacement cost or actual cash value?: tdi.texas.gov
  • Texas Department of Insurance — Replacing your roof: tdi.texas.gov
  • Texas Department of Insurance — Complaint indexes and policy counts (Texas Open Data Portal): data.texas.gov
  • J.D. Power — 2026 U.S. Home Insurance Study press release, Sept. 15, 2026 (reprint): insurancenewsnet.com
  • AM Best — State Farm action incl. State Farm Lloyds, Nov. 14, 2025 (reprint): insurancenewsnet.com
  • AM Best — Allstate affirmation, Sept. 2, 2026 (reprint): insurancenewsnet.com
  • AM Best — USAA affirmation, July 2, 2025 (reprint): insurancenewsnet.com
  • Travelers — 2025 Form 10-K (A++ rating table; AM Best affirmation Aug. 8, 2025): sec.gov
  • Liberty Mutual — Financial Ratings (AM Best A, stable): libertymutualgroup.com
  • AM Best — American Family affirmation, Sept. 24, 2025 (Business Wire reprint): financialcontent.com
  • AM Best — Nationwide outlook revised to positive, Nov. 2026: insurancenewsnet.com
  • NAIC — Consumer Insurance Search: content.naic.org

Related Reading

About the author

Evan Larson — Licensed Insurance Agent at Better Choice Insurance Group, an independent insurance agency in St. Charles, Illinois licensed in 14 states.

Last reviewed: November 2026

Find the Best Carrier for Your Texas Home

We compare identical coverage, deductibles and roof terms across the carriers we represent and tell you honestly where your current policy stands.

Get Your Free Quote