Mon–Fri: 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
(847) 908-5665  |  [email protected]

Best Car Insurance Companies in Texas (2026): How to Compare

November 2026  |  10 min read  |  By Evan Larson, Licensed Insurance Agent
Written and reviewed by Evan Larson, Licensed Insurance Agent  ·  Updated November 2026

Quick answer: No company wins on price for every Texas driver, so we ranked the largest Texas auto insurers on public data instead. Using the Texas Department of Insurance's 2024 and 2025 confirmed-complaint rates, with AM Best financial strength as a gate, Texas Farm Bureau, State Farm, Nationwide and Progressive ranked highest. J.D. Power's 2026 Texas winner was AAA (Automobile Club of Southern California). Texas minimums are 30/60/25. We quote Progressive, Travelers, Liberty Mutual, Nationwide and GEICO.

Texas has one of the largest auto insurance markets in the country: $35.4 billion in private passenger auto premium in 2025, written by 69 insurance groups, according to TDI's 2025 Market Conditions Annual Report. With that many choices, "best" lists are everywhere, and few show their work. This one uses only public data, and where a figure isn't published, the table says so.

We're an independent agency with an office in San Antonio. We've marked which companies we quote and ranked the ones we don't sell exactly where the data puts them.

How Did We Rank Texas Car Insurance Companies?

  1. Who's included. The ten largest groups by 2025 Texas private passenger auto premium in TDI's report, plus the group behind J.D. Power's 2026 Texas winner and Nationwide, a carrier we quote.
  2. Financial strength gate. AM Best's Financial Strength Rating and the date of the latest action we could verify. Every rating we verified is A (Excellent) or higher.
  3. Rank order: complaints. TDI lists confirmed complaints and policies written for the top 25 auto groups in 2025 and 2024. We converted TDI's "percent of complaints per policy" to complaints per 10,000 policies and ranked on the two years combined, lowest first (our calculation from TDI's counts).
  4. J.D. Power. Only what its 2026 press release states for the Texas region.

Not published means we couldn't find the figure in a public primary source we were able to access and verify for this article. We didn't estimate; each group is ranked on the data that exists. Price isn't ranked, because it depends on the driver.

Best Car Insurance Companies in Texas: The Ranked Table

Rank Insurance group (TDI name) Do we quote it? TX auto market share, 2025
Source: TDI
Confirmed complaints per 10,000 policies, 2025 / 2024
Source: TDI
Two-year rate
Our calc. from TDI
AM Best FSR (action date)
Source: AM Best releases
J.D. Power 2026, Texas region
Source: press release
1Texas Farm Bureau Mutual GroupNot through us3.05%0.27 / 0.320.30not publishednot published
2State Farm GroupNot through us (captive)17.85%0.28 / 0.360.32A+ (lowered from A++ Nov. 14, 2025)not published
3Nationwide Corporation GroupYes0.44%0.26 / 0.400.34*A, positive outlook (Nov. 2026)not published
4Progressive GroupYes23.21%0.34 / 0.340.34*A+ (affirmed May 1, 2026)not published
5Allstate Insurance GroupNot through us (captive)10.47%0.43 / 0.400.41A+ (affirmed Sept. 2, 2026)not published
6Berkshire Hathaway Group (GEICO)Yes (GEICO)10.33%0.60 / 0.300.46A++ for GEICO members (affirmed Nov. 29, 2023)not published
7Farmers Insurance GroupNot through us5.21%0.60 / 0.780.69not publishednot published
8Liberty Mutual GroupYes2.19%0.95 / 0.930.94A (stable, per Liberty Mutual)not published
9Auto Club Enterprises Insurance Group (AAA)Not through us1.79%1.15 / 0.861.00not publishedHighest in region: Automobile Club of Southern CA (AAA), 673
10United Services Automobile Assoc. GroupNot through us8.88%1.22 / 1.351.28A++ (affirmed July 2, 2025)not published
11Incline Insurance Group LLC GroupNot through us2.67%1.19 / 1.391.29not publishednot published
12Orpheus GroupNot through us2.15%2.11 / 1.751.95not publishednot published

All Texas auto insurers: 0.70 confirmed complaints per 10,000 policies in 2025 (2,235 complaints on 32,152,141 policies) and 0.69 in 2024. *Nationwide (0.340) and Progressive (0.341) separate only at the third decimal, and Nationwide's rate rests on just 2 and 4 confirmed complaints. TDI counts a policy with both liability and physical damage coverage in each category. J.D. Power names "Automobile Club of Southern CA (AAA)"; in TDI's data, AAA-affiliated insurers such as Auto Club County Mutual appear under Auto Club Enterprises Insurance Group. AM Best sources are listed at the end of this article.

What Does the Ranking Tell You?

The big three are all below the statewide rate. Progressive, State Farm and Allstate wrote a combined 51.5% of Texas auto premium in 2025, and each posted a two-year complaint rate well under the 0.69 market figure.

Complaints and satisfaction surveys measure different things. The AAA group that topped J.D. Power's Texas region ranks ninth here on TDI complaints. Neither measure is wrong; one counts confirmed complaints to a regulator, the other surveys customers.

Our own carriers are spread out. Nationwide and Progressive ranked third and fourth; Liberty Mutual ranked eighth, above the market rate. Travelers, which we also quote, isn't among TDI's top 25 Texas auto groups, so it isn't in the table.

What Are Texas' Minimum Car Insurance Requirements?

TDI's auto insurance guide says Texas law requires at least $30,000 for injuries per person, $60,000 per accident, and $25,000 for property damage: 30/60/25. Two more Texas-specific rules:

  • Personal injury protection is included in all Texas auto policies; if you don't want it, you must tell the company in writing.
  • Uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage must be offered; rejecting it also has to be in writing.

TDI also cautions that minimum limits "might be too low if you cause a multi-vehicle accident or the other driver's car is totaled." When you compare carriers, compare the same limits. For city specifics, see our Houston, San Antonio, Austin and Fort Worth auto insurance pages.

Are Texas Auto Rates Going Down?

For many drivers, yes. In its October 8, 2026 release, TDI said auto insurers filed rate decreases affecting 4.4 million policyholders since July 1, 2026. Examples:

  • Auto Club County Mutual Insurance Company: 3% decrease, 235,000 policyholders.
  • Loya Insurance Company: 10.3% decrease, 39,000 policyholders.

Gov. Greg Abbott said "these filings show lower rates for many Texas homeowners and drivers," and Commissioner Amanda Crawford encouraged Texans to "shop around." A filed decrease is an average; your renewal depends on your drivers, vehicles and record. If yours went up anyway, see what to do when a renewal goes up and our look at late-2026 repair costs and tariffs.

Where Does J.D. Power Fit for Texas Drivers?

J.D. Power's 2026 U.S. Auto Insurance Study, released June 9, 2026 and based on 52,216 customer responses fielded April 2025 through April 2026, has a dedicated Texas region. Automobile Club of Southern California (AAA) ranked highest there at 673. Nationally, Nationwide ranked highest for usage-based insurance programs at 711. The press release doesn't publish other carriers' Texas scores, so we haven't listed any.

Which Carriers Do We Quote, and Which Can't We?

We represent Progressive, Travelers, Liberty Mutual, Nationwide and GEICO, plus the rest of a 22+ carrier panel. Eligibility depends on drivers, vehicles and record. Head-to-head reading: State Farm vs. Progressive, Allstate vs. Progressive, Progressive vs. GEICO and Progressive vs. Safeco.

State Farm and Allstate are captive carriers. State Farm sells only through its own agents; we can't quote it, but we can quote the carriers above against your current State Farm policy, and the same goes for Allstate. Other groups marked "not through us" aren't carriers we quote here, and several outranked some of our carriers on complaints. See independent vs. captive agents, switching from State Farm and switching from Allstate.

How Do I Check a Texas Auto Insurer Myself?

  1. Find the writing company on your ID card or declarations page. Texas auto is often written through county mutual companies, so the name may differ from the brand.
  2. Look it up in TDI's complaint index data set, linked from TDI's complaint data page. The average index is 1.00; below 1 means fewer complaints than average.
  3. Check the NAIC Consumer Insurance Search for a national view.
  4. Confirm the current AM Best rating; ratings change, as State Farm's November 2025 action shows.

Get Them Quoted Side by Side

We quote Progressive, Travelers, Liberty Mutual, Nationwide and GEICO side by side with one form, on identical limits and deductibles, subject to each carrier's eligibility. The online quick quote takes about three minutes and a licensed agent calls you back; quotes are free and no obligation. If your current carrier is still the best value, we'll say so. For clients, we review every renewal and re-shop when an increase is out of line. Call (847) 908-5665 (Mon–Fri, 9 AM–6 PM), visit our San Antonio office at 106 S Saint Marys St, Suite 265, or start a full quote.

Want your Texas auto policy checked against the market? Send us your declarations page and we'll quote identical limits and deductibles across the carriers we represent. Free, no obligation; the online form takes about three minutes. Rated 4.9 stars on Google from 130+ reviews.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best car insurance company in Texas?

No single company is best for every Texas driver, because each carrier prices your age, vehicle, ZIP code, driving record and credit-based insurance score differently. On the public data we used, Texas Farm Bureau Mutual Group, State Farm Group, Nationwide and Progressive Group had the lowest rates of confirmed complaints per policy among the Texas auto insurers we reviewed in the Texas Department of Insurance's 2024 and 2025 figures. Complaint data is a service signal, not a price verdict, so compare identical quotes before choosing.

What is the minimum car insurance required in Texas?

Texas requires liability coverage of at least $30,000 for injuries per person, $60,000 per accident, and $25,000 for property damage, known as 30/60/25, according to the Texas Department of Insurance. Personal injury protection is included in every Texas auto policy unless you reject it in writing, and insurers must offer uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage, which you must also reject in writing if you don't want it.

Who is the largest car insurance company in Texas?

Progressive. In the Texas Department of Insurance's 2025 Market Conditions Annual Report, Progressive Group wrote 23.21% of Texas private passenger auto premium in 2025, followed by State Farm Group at 17.85% and Allstate Insurance Group at 10.47%. Market share measures size, not price or service quality.

Are car insurance rates going down in Texas?

For many drivers, yes. On October 8, 2026, the Texas Department of Insurance said auto insurers had filed rate decreases affecting 4.4 million policyholders since July 1, 2026, including a 3% decrease from Auto Club County Mutual Insurance Company affecting 235,000 policyholders and a 10.3% decrease from Loya Insurance Company affecting 39,000. Your own renewal can still move differently.

Which car insurer ranked highest for customer satisfaction in Texas?

In J.D. Power's 2026 U.S. Auto Insurance Study, released June 9, 2026, Automobile Club of Southern California (AAA) ranked highest in the Texas region with a score of 673 on a 1,000-point scale. The press release names only the regional winner, so it does not tell you how other carriers scored in Texas.

Can Better Choice quote State Farm or Allstate in Texas?

No. State Farm and Allstate sell through their own captive agents, so we cannot quote them. We can quote carriers we represent, including Progressive, Travelers, Liberty Mutual and Nationwide, subject to each carrier's eligibility for your drivers and vehicles, against your current State Farm or Allstate declarations page so you can compare identical coverage.

Sources

  • Texas Department of Insurance — 2025 Market Conditions Annual Report (March 2026; market share and complaint tables): tdi.texas.gov (PDF)
  • Texas Department of Insurance — "Home and auto insurance rates trending down for many Texans," Oct. 8, 2026: tdi.texas.gov
  • Texas Department of Insurance — Auto insurance guide (30/60/25, PIP, UM/UIM): tdi.texas.gov
  • Texas Department of Insurance — Complaint indexes and policy counts (Texas Open Data Portal): data.texas.gov
  • J.D. Power — 2026 U.S. Auto Insurance Study press release, June 9, 2026 (reprint): insurancenewsnet.com
  • AM Best — State Farm action, Nov. 14, 2025 (reprint): insurancenewsnet.com
  • AM Best — Progressive affirmation, May 1, 2026 (reprint): insurancenewsnet.com
  • AM Best — Allstate affirmation, Sept. 2, 2026 (reprint): insurancenewsnet.com
  • AM Best — GEICO affirmation, Nov. 29, 2023 (reprint): insurancenewsnet.com
  • AM Best — USAA affirmation, July 2, 2025 (reprint): insurancenewsnet.com
  • Liberty Mutual — Financial Ratings (AM Best A, stable): libertymutualgroup.com
  • AM Best — Nationwide outlook revised to positive, Nov. 2026: insurancenewsnet.com
  • NAIC — Consumer Insurance Search: content.naic.org

Related Reading

About the author

Evan Larson — Licensed Insurance Agent at Better Choice Insurance Group, an independent insurance agency in St. Charles, Illinois licensed in 14 states.

Last reviewed: November 2026

Compare Texas Auto Carriers on Your Driving Record

We quote identical coverage across the carriers we represent and tell you honestly where your current policy stands.

Get Your Free Quote