Quick answer: No company wins on price for every Illinois driver, so we ranked the largest Illinois auto insurers on public data instead. Using the Illinois Department of Insurance's 2024 and 2025 complaint ratios, with AM Best financial strength as a gate, COUNTRY Financial, Travelers, Erie and American Family had the lowest complaint ratios among the largest writers; State Farm, the state's largest writer, ranked fifth. We quote Travelers, Progressive, Liberty Mutual, Nationwide, Grange, Mercury and GEICO, and can price them against any current policy.
Most "best car insurance in Illinois" lists use star scores nobody can trace to a source. Here, every column in the table comes from a public source you can check, and where a figure isn't published, the cell says so.
We're an independent agency, so we have a stake here. We've marked which companies we quote, and ranked the ones we don't sell exactly where the data puts them. Several come out ahead of carriers we represent.
How Did We Rank Illinois Car Insurance Companies?
Price can't be ranked honestly: the order changes with age, vehicle, ZIP code, driving record and credit-based insurance score. So we ranked on what is published and comparable:
- Who's included. The ten largest auto insurance brands in Illinois by private passenger auto liability premium in the Illinois Department of Insurance's 2024 Property and Casualty Market Share Report, plus every carrier we quote. The IDOI reports individual writing companies, not groups, so each brand is represented by its largest Illinois auto company.
- Financial strength gate. AM Best's Financial Strength Rating, with the date of the most recent rating action we could verify. Every carrier with a verified rating here is A (Excellent) or higher.
- Rank order: complaint record. The IDOI's 2025 Consumer Complaints Ratio Report and 2024 report list complaints per $1 million of Illinois auto earned premium for every company with five or more auto complaints. We ranked on the two years combined (total complaints divided by total earned premium, our calculation from the IDOI figures), lowest first. Two years smooths out one bad or lucky year.
- J.D. Power. Only results stated in J.D. Power's own press release. J.D. Power does not publish an Illinois-only ranking.
Where we write not published, we could not find that figure in a public primary source we were able to access and verify for this article. We didn't estimate it, and the carrier is ranked on the data that does exist.
Best Car Insurance Companies in Illinois: The Ranked Table
| Rank | Carrier (largest IL auto company) | Do we quote it? | IL auto liability market share, 2024 Source: IDOI |
Complaints per $1M premium, 2025 / 2024 Source: IDOI |
Two-year ratio Our calc. from IDOI |
AM Best FSR (action date) Source: AM Best releases |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | COUNTRY Financial (COUNTRY Preferred Ins. Co.) | Not through us | 4.74% | 0.0381 / 0.0453 | 0.042 | not published |
| 2 | Travelers (Standard Fire Ins. Co.) | Yes | 1.85% | 0.1064 / 0.1229 | 0.115 | A++ (affirmed Aug. 8, 2025) |
| 3 | Erie (Erie Ins. Exchange) | Not through us | 1.50% | 0.1397 / 0.0914 | 0.117 | A (affirmed Sept. 11, 2026) |
| 4 | American Family (American Family Ins. Co.) | Not through us | 1.88% | 0.1110 / 0.1329 | 0.123 | A (affirmed Sept. 24, 2025) |
| 5 | State Farm (State Farm Mutual Automobile Ins. Co.) | Not through us (captive) | 28.72% | 0.1625 / 0.1466 | 0.155 | A+ (lowered from A++ Nov. 14, 2025) |
| 6 | Allstate (Allstate Fire & Casualty Ins. Co.) | Not through us (captive) | 7.81% | 0.1833 / 0.1672 | 0.175* | A+ (affirmed Sept. 2, 2026) |
| 7 | GEICO (GEICO Secure Ins. Co.) | Yes | 2.59% | 0.1953 / 0.1575 | 0.175* | A++ (affirmed Nov. 29, 2023) |
| 8 | Liberty Mutual, formerly Safeco (Safeco Ins. Co. of IL) | Yes | 0.84% | 0.2431 / 0.2325 | 0.237 | A (stable, per Liberty Mutual) |
| 9 | Progressive (Progressive Universal Ins. Co.) | Yes | 8.08% | 0.3047 / 0.2256 | 0.269 | A+ (affirmed May 1, 2026) |
| 10 | AAA (Auto Club Ins. Association) | Not through us | 1.30% | 0.2501 / 0.3160 | 0.281 | not published |
| 11 | Mercury (Mercury Ins. Co. of Illinois) | Yes | 0.16% | 0.4131 / not listed | 2025 only | A (affirmed Feb. 24, 2026) |
| 12 | American Alliance Casualty Co. | Not through us | 1.44% | 3.8313 / 4.5677 | 4.229 | not published |
| Unranked | Nationwide (Nationwide General Ins. Co.) | Yes | 0.16% | not listed / not listed | — | A, positive outlook (Nov. 2026) |
| Unranked | Grange (Grange Indemnity Ins. Co.) | Yes | under 0.01% | not listed / not listed | — | A (reaffirmed Aug. 28, 2025) |
Industry mean (all auto companies): 0.2657 complaints per $1 million of earned premium in 2025 and 0.2688 in 2024; 0.267 for the two years combined. *Allstate (0.1746) and GEICO (0.1750) separate only at the fourth decimal. "Not listed" means the company had fewer than five Illinois auto complaints that year, so the IDOI did not list it individually; that is why Nationwide and Grange can't be ranked on this measure, and why Mercury is ranked on 2025 alone. IDOI complaint figures cover all auto coverage written by that company. AM Best sources are listed at the end of this article. J.D. Power: see the next section.
What Does the Ranking Actually Tell You?
Three things stand out.
Most big carriers sit below the industry mean. Eight of the twelve ranked companies had a two-year complaint ratio under 0.267. In the 2025 report, the IDOI recorded 3,786 auto complaints statewide, and claims handling was the most common complaint reason across all lines. State Farm Mutual drew 550 auto complaints in 2025, but on $3.38 billion of earned premium that is a below-average 0.1625.
Size and service are different questions. State Farm writes more than a quarter of Illinois auto liability premium on its own and lands mid-table on complaints. COUNTRY Preferred writes 4.74% and posted the lowest ratio of any large writer in both years. Neither fact tells you which company will price your household best.
One outlier is worth checking. American Alliance Casualty Company's ratio was more than 14 times the industry mean in both years. We report that as published; if you hold a policy with any carrier near the bottom of a regulator's list, it is reasonable to ask your agent about it or contact the Illinois Department of Insurance.
Where Does J.D. Power Fit for Illinois Drivers?
J.D. Power's 2026 U.S. Auto Insurance Study (released June 9, 2026, based on 52,216 customer responses fielded April 2025 through April 2026) ranks satisfaction in 11 regions. The press release names one winner per region; for the North Central region it is Erie Insurance, at 688 on a 1,000-point scale, for a sixth consecutive year. Separately, Nationwide ranked highest for usage-based insurance programs, at 711.
The press release doesn't list which states make up each region or publish other carriers' scores, so we haven't put J.D. Power numbers next to any other name.
How Do the Carriers We Quote Compare?
We represent Travelers, Progressive, Liberty Mutual (formerly Safeco), Nationwide, Grange and Mercury in Illinois, plus the rest of a 22+ carrier panel. Here's how they show up in the data, good and less good:
- Travelers ranked second on complaints and carries an A++ from AM Best, the highest verified rating in the table.
- Progressive is the second-largest auto writer in Illinois. Its largest company sat slightly above the industry mean in 2025 and below it in 2024. Our Progressive vs. GEICO and Progressive vs. Safeco comparisons go deeper.
- Liberty Mutual (formerly Safeco) came in below the mean both years.
- Mercury is a smaller Illinois writer; with fewer than five complaints in 2024 and seven in 2025, its ratio moves a lot on small numbers. We hold an Illinois appointment with Mercury for both home and auto; see our Mercury vs. Progressive breakdown.
- Nationwide and Grange had too few Illinois auto complaints to be listed by the IDOI in either year, so we can't rank them on this measure.
Why Can't We Quote State Farm, Allstate or COUNTRY?
State Farm and Allstate are captive carriers: State Farm sells only through its own agents, and Allstate works the same way. We can't quote either, but we can quote the carriers above against your current policy. The other names marked "not through us" aren't carriers we quote for this comparison. That doesn't make them worse; several outranked our own carriers on complaints. If you're weighing a move, our guides on switching from State Farm, switching State Farm agents and switching from Allstate walk through it, and independent vs. captive agents explains the trade-off.
What Should Illinois Drivers Compare Besides the Ranking?
- Liability limits. The IDOI's auto shopping guide lists the Illinois minimums: $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident for bodily injury, $20,000 for property damage, and uninsured motorist bodily injury at $25,000/$50,000. Our Illinois auto insurance minimums guide explains why many drivers carry more.
- Identical deductibles and coverages. A quote with a $1,000 collision deductible isn't comparable to one at $500.
- Credit-based insurance score. It can move your auto price at many carriers; see how credit affects insurance rates.
- Bundling. Some carriers price auto differently with the home attached; see whether bundling is worth it and our bundled home and auto quotes.
Does the New Illinois Rate-Review Law Change Which Company to Pick?
Not this year. Senate Bill 714, the auto half of Illinois' new rate-review package, takes effect July 1, 2027, according to Insurance Journal. After that, the Department of Insurance has 40 days to tell an auto insurer a filing fails the law's requirements, and insurers must give at least 30 days' notice before raising a renewal premium 10% or more. Our rate-review law explainer covers the details. Until then, comparison is still the tool that works.
How Do I Check a Carrier Myself?
- Open the IDOI's consumer complaint reports and find the company name on your declarations page under Auto.
- Compare its ratio with the industry mean printed at the bottom of the table.
- Look up the same company in the NAIC Consumer Insurance Search for a national complaint index (1.00 is the baseline). We used the Illinois-specific numbers instead.
- Check AM Best's current rating; ratings change, as State Farm's November 2025 action shows.
Get Them Quoted Side by Side
We quote Travelers, Progressive, Liberty Mutual, Nationwide, Grange, Mercury and GEICO side by side with one form, on identical coverage, subject to each carrier's eligibility for your driver and vehicle. The online quick quote takes about three minutes and a licensed agent calls you back. Quotes are free and no obligation. If your current carrier is still the best value, we'll tell you. For our clients, we review every renewal and re-shop when an increase is out of line. Or call (847) 908-5665 (Mon–Fri, 9 AM–6 PM) or start a full quote.
Want your current auto policy checked against the market? Send us your declarations page and we'll quote identical coverage across the carriers we represent. Free, no obligation; the online form takes about three minutes. Rated 4.9 stars on Google from 130+ reviews.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best car insurance company in Illinois?
No single company is best for every Illinois driver, because each carrier prices your age, vehicle, ZIP code, driving record and credit-based insurance score differently. On the public data we used, COUNTRY Preferred Insurance Company had the lowest complaint ratio among the large Illinois auto writers we reviewed in the Illinois Department of Insurance's 2024 and 2025 reports, followed by Travelers' Standard Fire Insurance Company, Erie Insurance Exchange and American Family Insurance Company. Complaint data is a service signal, not a price verdict, so compare identical quotes before you choose.
Who is the largest car insurance company in Illinois?
State Farm. In the Illinois Department of Insurance's 2024 Property and Casualty Market Share Report, State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company wrote 28.72% of Illinois private passenger auto liability premium, followed by Progressive Universal Insurance Company at 8.08% and Allstate Fire and Casualty Insurance Company at 7.81%. Market share measures size, not price or service quality.
How do I check an insurance company's complaint record in Illinois?
The Illinois Department of Insurance publishes an annual Consumer Complaints Ratio Report that lists every company with five or more complaints by line of coverage, along with complaints per $1 million of Illinois earned premium and the industry mean. The 2025 auto industry mean was 0.2657. For a national view, the NAIC Consumer Insurance Search tool shows each company's complaint information and a complaint index where 1.00 is the baseline.
What are the minimum car insurance requirements in Illinois?
According to the Illinois Department of Insurance, Illinois requires liability limits of at least $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident for bodily injury and $20,000 for property damage, often written as 25/50/20, plus uninsured motorist bodily injury coverage of at least $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident. Many drivers carry higher limits because minimum limits can run out quickly in a serious accident. Ask your agent what limits fit your assets and household.
Does the new Illinois rate-review law affect my car insurance?
Not yet. Senate Bill 714 takes effect July 1, 2027, according to Insurance Journal. Once in effect, the Illinois Department of Insurance has 40 days to tell an auto insurer that a rate filing fails the law's requirements, and insurers must give at least 30 days' notice before increasing a renewal premium by 10% or more. It does not roll back current rates.
Can Better Choice quote State Farm or Allstate?
No. State Farm and Allstate sell through their own captive agents, so an independent agency cannot quote them. What we can do is quote the carriers we represent, including Travelers, Progressive, Liberty Mutual (formerly Safeco), Nationwide, Grange and Mercury, against your current State Farm or Allstate declarations page so you can compare identical coverage.
Sources
- Illinois Department of Insurance — 2024 Property and Casualty Market Share Report: idoi.illinois.gov (PDF)
- Illinois Department of Insurance — 2025 Consumer Complaints Ratio Report: idoi.illinois.gov (PDF)
- Illinois Department of Insurance — 2024 Consumer Complaints Ratio Report: idoi.illinois.gov (PDF)
- J.D. Power — 2026 U.S. Auto Insurance Study press release, June 9, 2026 (reprint): insurancenewsnet.com
- AM Best — State Farm action, Nov. 14, 2025 (reprint): insurancenewsnet.com
- AM Best — Allstate affirmation, Sept. 2, 2026 (reprint): insurancenewsnet.com
- AM Best — Progressive affirmation, May 1, 2026 (reprint): insurancenewsnet.com
- Travelers — 2025 Form 10-K (A++ rating table; AM Best affirmation Aug. 8, 2025): sec.gov
- AM Best — Erie Insurance Group affirmation, Sept. 11, 2026 (reprint): insurancenewsnet.com
- AM Best — American Family affirmation, Sept. 24, 2025 (Business Wire reprint): financialcontent.com
- AM Best — GEICO affirmation, Nov. 29, 2023 (reprint): insurancenewsnet.com
- Liberty Mutual — Financial Ratings (AM Best A, stable): libertymutualgroup.com
- AM Best — Mercury General affirmation, Feb. 24, 2026 (reprint): insurancenewsnet.com
- AM Best — Nationwide outlook revised to positive, Nov. 2026: insurancenewsnet.com
- Grange Insurance — "A.M. Best Reaffirms Grange Insurance's 'A' (Excellent) Rating," Aug. 28, 2025 (Business Wire reprint): financialcontent.com
- Illinois Department of Insurance — Auto Insurance Shopping Guide (minimum limits): idoi.illinois.gov
- NAIC — Consumer Insurance Search: content.naic.org
- Insurance Journal — Illinois rate-review bills (SB 714 effective date and notice rules), May 29, 2026: insurancejournal.com
Related Reading
- Best Home Insurance Companies in Illinois (2026)
- Best Car Insurance Companies in Texas (2026)
- State Farm vs. Progressive Auto Insurance
- Allstate vs. Progressive Auto Insurance
- How to Lower Auto Insurance Rates in Illinois
- Better Choice vs. Allstate
About the author
Evan Larson — Licensed Insurance Agent at Better Choice Insurance Group, an independent insurance agency in St. Charles, Illinois licensed in 14 states.
Last reviewed: November 2026