Quick answer: No company is best for every San Antonio home. TDI county data shows 2025 average premiums of $2,806 in Bexar, $2,803 in Comal and $2,659 in Guadalupe, below the $3,489 statewide average (preliminary) but up 7% to 10% from 2024. Wind and hail caused 54% of the three counties' homeowners paid losses from 2019 to 2025, and flash flooding isn't covered by a homeowners policy. So compare the wind/hail deductible in dollars, roof terms and flood first. On TDI's statewide complaint data, Texas Farm Bureau, Progressive, Farmers and Travelers ranked highest.
Unlike Dallas–Fort Worth and Houston, San Antonio's average home insurance premium sits below the state average. That doesn't make hail or flash flooding less real here. This guide uses what the Texas Department of Insurance (TDI) publishes for Bexar, Comal and Guadalupe counties, then ranks companies on TDI's complaint data, which is statewide. We're an independent agency with an office downtown, so we mark which companies we quote and leave the rest where the data puts them.
How Much Is Home Insurance in San Antonio?
Less than the Texas average, but rising. TDI's homeowners market overview puts the statewide 2025 average at $3,489 (preliminary). Its county map data shows:
| County | Avg. premium, 2025 | vs. $3,489 statewide | Avg. premium, 2024 | Avg. insured amount, 2025 | FAIR Plan policies |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bexar | $2,806 | −20% | $2,579 | $398,000 | 1,023 |
| Comal | $2,803 | −20% | $2,614 | $490,000 | 120 |
| Guadalupe | $2,659 | −24% | $2,421 | $397,000 | 84 |
TDI's county map reports the average premium for homeowners policies that include wind coverage; the $3,489 statewide figure is TDI's overall 2025 preliminary average, so treat the comparison as close, not exact. Weighting TDI's 2025 county figures by policy count gives about $3,533 statewide for policies with wind (our calculation). County figures from TDI's county premium map data.
Weighted by policy count, the three counties averaged about $2,794 in 2025 across roughly 524,000 policies with wind coverage (our calculation). Averages still rose 7% to 10% from 2024, and Bexar County's has climbed from $1,510 in 2019. Comal stands out: its average insured amount is $92,000 higher than Bexar's, yet its average premium is about the same.
The FAIR Plan, Texas's insurer of last resort, plays a small role here: about 1,200 policies across the three counties, versus 28,616 in Harris County alone. TDI counts 117 to 125 companies writing homeowners premium in each county. City detail is on our San Antonio and San Antonio home insurance pages, and Comal County owners can see New Braunfels home insurance.
What Damages San Antonio Homes Most?
Wind and hail, then water. TDI's homeowners losses by county data, 2019 through 2025:
| County | Wind/hail share of paid losses, 2019–25 | Water share | Wind/hail paid per policy, 2025 | Worst wind/hail year per policy |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bexar | 53% | 28% | $594 | 2020: $804 |
| Comal | 58% | 23% | $305 | 2021: $972 |
| Guadalupe | 51% | 27% | $247 | 2022: $1,003 |
| All Texas counties | 61% | 23% | $1,010 | – |
Source: TDI homeowners losses by county, 2019–2025 paid losses; shares and per-policy averages are our calculations. TDI's county file has four loss types (wind, water, fire, other) and no separate hail line; its 2021 statewide wind total equals TDI's separately published statewide wind plus hail figures, so we read "wind" as wind and hail. Flood isn't in these numbers: TDI notes most home policies don't cover flood. TWIA wind losses are excluded.
Two patterns matter for shoppers. First, San Antonio's wind/hail payouts averaged about $546 per policy per year over seven years, against about $900 statewide (our calculation). That lines up with the lower premiums. Second, the direction isn't steady: Bexar County's wind/hail losses per policy rose 21% in 2025 to $248 million in total, while Comal's fell 40%.
Water was 27% of paid losses across the three counties. In 2021 Bexar water losses jumped to $169 million from $73 million the year before; TDI's winter weather report ties the February 11–19, 2021 freeze to "freezing pipes" and related water damage. Those are claims homeowners policies paid; flood is separate.
What Does That Mean for Your Wind and Hail Deductible?
TDI's deductibles guide shows a 5% deductible on a $150,000 home is $7,500, so a $6,500 hail repair pays nothing, and notes the deductible applies to each claim. On a home insured near Bexar County's $398,000 average, a 1% deductible is $3,980 and 2% is $7,960; near Comal's $490,000, they're $4,900 and $9,800 (our arithmetic).
Because San Antonio premiums are lower, the yearly savings from a higher deductible can be smaller in dollars than in DFW. Price two deductible levels with each carrier and weigh the yearly difference against the extra you'd pay on a claim. Our Texas wind/hail deductible explainer walks through it.
What About Roof Terms?
TDI's roof guide warns that "as roofs age, some companies will switch to actual cash value," and tells homeowners to check roof coverage at every renewal. TDI also notes companies often discount roofs made of damage-resistant materials (discount guide). See our FORTIFIED roof discount guide and ACV vs. replacement cost on roof claims.
Do San Antonio Homeowners Need Flood Insurance?
It deserves a serious look, even away from the rivers. TDI's flood guide says "most home insurance policies don't cover flood damage," that on average 40% of NFIP claims occur outside high-risk flood areas, and that most flood policies have a 30-day wait. NFIP limits are $250,000 for the home and $100,000 for belongings.
San Antonio's flash-flood risk is local and fast: Texas Public Radio reported that 13 people died after heavy rain on June 12, 2025, with the main site at Beitel Creek on the Northeast Side. Flood doesn't show in the loss table above because homeowners policies don't pay it. For creeks, low-water crossings and Bexar's maps, read flood insurance in San Antonio; for Comal and the Guadalupe River, see Hill Country flood insurance.
Which Home Insurance Companies Rank Best?
TDI publishes complaint figures statewide, not by county, so this is the same table as our statewide Texas ranking, not a San Antonio measurement. It ranks the largest groups on confirmed complaints per policy for 2024 and 2025 combined, from TDI's 2025 Market Conditions Annual Report.
| Rank | Insurance group | Do we quote it? | TX market share, 2025 | Complaints per 10,000 policies, 2024–25 Our calc. from TDI |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Texas Farm Bureau | Not through us | 2.44% | 0.56 |
| 2 | Progressive (ASI) | Yes | 2.39% | 0.61 |
| 3 | Farmers | Not through us | 8.15% | 0.80 |
| 4 | Travelers | Yes | 5.15% | 0.92 |
| 5 | State Farm | No (captive) | 19.10% | 1.37 |
| 6 | USAA | Not through us | 11.22% | 1.44 |
| 7 | Allstate | No (captive) | 16.79% | 1.46 |
| 8 | Iron Family Holdings | Not through us | 2.38% | 1.59 |
| 9 | Liberty Mutual | Yes | 6.05% | 1.81 |
| 10 | American Family | Not through us | 3.98% | 1.82 |
| 11 | Nationwide | Yes | 1.36% | 2.66 |
All Texas homeowners insurers: 1.34 confirmed complaints per 10,000 policies in 2025 and 1.37 in 2024 (TDI). Every AM Best rating we could verify was A (Excellent) or higher; details are in the statewide guide. Small groups' rates swing more year to year.
Which Carriers Can We Quote in San Antonio?
We represent Travelers, Progressive, Liberty Mutual and Nationwide, plus the rest of a 22+ carrier panel. Three of the panel's home carriers list Texas on their own sites:
- Bamboo announced its Texas Essential Homeowner Program on September 4, 2026; it says policyholders can tailor roof coverage, water coverage and loss settlement options.
- Orion180 lists Texas among the states it serves. Its FLEX policy starts "with basic perils like fire and lightning," then adds protections "like wind, storm, or water damage." Confirm wind and hail are on any FLEX quote you compare.
- Hippo publishes a Texas homeowners insurance page.
All are subject to eligibility for the address. None is in the table above; check them in TDI's complaint index data set. We also quote GEICO, for auto only.
State Farm sells only through its own agents; we can't quote it, but we can quote the carriers above against your current State Farm policy. Allstate is also a captive carrier, and the same applies. We don't quote Farmers, USAA or Texas Farm Bureau either, and on the data Texas Farm Bureau and Farmers ranked above most of our carriers. See independent vs. captive agents and switching from State Farm.
How Do I Get San Antonio Quotes Side by Side?
We quote Travelers, Progressive, Liberty Mutual, Nationwide and our other Texas home carriers side by side with one form, on the same dwelling limit, wind/hail deductible in dollars and roof terms, subject to each carrier's eligibility for the address. The online quick quote takes about three minutes and a licensed agent calls you back; quotes are free and no obligation. If your current policy is the better value, we'll say so. For clients, we review every renewal and re-shop when an increase is out of line. Call (847) 908-5665 (Mon–Fri, 9 AM–6 PM), visit our San Antonio office at 106 S Saint Marys St, Suite 265,, or start a full quote.
Want your San Antonio home compared on identical coverage? Send us your declarations page and we'll match the dwelling limit, wind/hail deductible and roof terms across the carriers we represent. Free, no obligation; the online form takes about three minutes. Rated 4.9 stars on Google from 130+ reviews.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best home insurance company in San Antonio?
No single company is best for every San Antonio home, because carriers price roof age, construction, deductibles and claims history differently. Texas Department of Insurance complaint data is published statewide, not by county; on that data, Texas Farm Bureau, Progressive, Farmers and Travelers had the lowest confirmed-complaint rates among the largest Texas home insurers for 2024 and 2025. In San Antonio, compare the wind and hail deductible in dollars, the roof terms and a separate flood policy before you compare company names.
How much is homeowners insurance in San Antonio?
Texas Department of Insurance county data shows 2025 average premiums for policies with wind coverage of $2,806 in Bexar County, $2,803 in Comal and $2,659 in Guadalupe, all below the $3,489 statewide average (preliminary). Averages rose 7% to 10% from 2024 to 2025 in the three counties.
Why is home insurance in San Antonio below the Texas average?
TDI's data shows two differences. From 2019 through 2025, wind and hail payouts in Bexar, Comal and Guadalupe counties averaged about $546 per policy per year, against about $900 statewide, by our calculation. Bexar and Guadalupe homes also carry lower average insured amounts, about $398,000 and $397,000. Lower than average still means roughly $2,700 to $2,800 a year.
Does homeowners insurance cover flash flooding in San Antonio?
Usually not. The Texas Department of Insurance says most home insurance policies don't cover flood damage, so you need a separate flood policy. NFIP coverage goes up to $250,000 for the home and $100,000 for belongings, and most flood policies have a 30-day waiting period.
What wind and hail deductible should I choose in San Antonio?
Pick the largest deductible you could pay in cash after a hailstorm, and convert any percentage to dollars first. On a home insured for $398,000, about the Bexar County average, a 1% deductible is $3,980 and a 2% deductible is $7,960. The Texas Department of Insurance notes that a deductible applies to each claim.
Can Better Choice quote State Farm or Allstate in San Antonio?
No. State Farm and Allstate sell through their own captive agents, so we can't quote them. We can quote Travelers, Progressive, Liberty Mutual, Nationwide and our other Texas home carriers, subject to eligibility for the address, against your current State Farm or Allstate declarations page. Our Texas office is at 106 S Saint Marys St, Suite 265, in downtown San Antonio.
Sources
- Texas Department of Insurance — Texas homeowners insurance market overview ($3,489 2025 preliminary average; county map definitions; FAIR and TWIA): tdi.texas.gov
- Texas Department of Insurance — county average premium map data, 2019–2025 (Texas Statistical Plan for Residential Risks; Tableau Public data export): public.tableau.com
- Texas Department of Insurance — Texas homeowners losses by county (updated June 22, 2026): tdi.texas.gov; data file: home-owners-losses-by-county-25.csv
- Texas Department of Insurance — 2025 Market Conditions Annual Report (market share and complaint tables): tdi.texas.gov (PDF)
- Texas Department of Insurance — Complaint indexes and policy counts (Texas Open Data Portal): data.texas.gov
- Texas Department of Insurance — What to know about deductibles: tdi.texas.gov
- Texas Department of Insurance — Insurance and your roof: tdi.texas.gov
- Texas Department of Insurance — Lower your home insurance cost by asking for discounts: tdi.texas.gov
- Texas Department of Insurance — Flood insurance: Why you need a policy: tdi.texas.gov
- Texas Department of Insurance — Insured Losses Resulting from the February 2021 Texas Winter Weather Event (Nov. 2022): tdi.texas.gov (PDF)
- Bamboo Insurance — Texas Essential Homeowner Program announcement, Sept. 4, 2026: bambooinsurance.com
- Orion180 — Texas: orion180.com
- Hippo — Homeowners insurance in Texas: hippo.com
- Texas Public Radio — "All 13 people killed in early June flash flood in San Antonio identified," June 30, 2025: tpr.org
Related Reading
- Best Home Insurance Companies in Texas (2026)
- Flood Insurance in San Antonio, TX
- Flood Insurance in the Texas Hill Country
- Texas Wind and Hail Deductibles Explained
- FORTIFIED Roof Discounts in Texas
- Best Home Insurance in Austin (2026)
About the author
Evan Larson — Licensed Insurance Agent at Better Choice Insurance Group, an independent insurance agency in St. Charles, Illinois licensed in 14 states.
Last reviewed: November 2026