Quick answer: Farmers and Travelers are both highly rated home insurers (AM Best: Travelers A++, Farmers group members A). The practical difference is how you buy them: Farmers-branded home policies come through Farmers agents or Farmers directly, while Travelers sells through independent agents who can price it next to other carriers. Neither is cheaper across the board; compare the same dwelling limit, deductibles and endorsements from your declarations page.
If you have a Farmers homeowners policy and a renewal coming, here is how it lines up with Travelers. A disclosure up front: we are an independent agency. We quote Travelers. We are not a Farmers agency, so we can't quote a Farmers-branded home policy; we can quote Travelers and the other carriers on our panel against your current Farmers policy. Everything below about Farmers comes from Farmers' own pages or published reports.
What Is the Main Difference Between Farmers and Travelers?
Distribution. Farmers says it reaches customers through "a network of Farmers Insurance® exclusive agencies," "tens of thousands of independent agents," and "direct sales online and through company call centers" (Farmers). Its homeowners pages send you to "Find a Farmers agent" and tell you to "ask your Farmers agent for more details" (Farmers). A Farmers exclusive agent represents Farmers, so the home price you see there is Farmers' price. For background, see independent vs. captive agents.
Travelers sells through independent agents. In its own words, "some insurance agents work for only one company, so they can't offer you a choice of brands and policies," while "independent agents aren't held captive by one company" (Travelers).
How Do Foremost and Bristol West Fit In?
Farmers' companies page lists Foremost, which "offers customizable, standard to preferred auto, home and umbrella policies," and Bristol West, which "provides private passenger non-standard auto insurance." Foremost says it was "acquired by the Farmers Insurance Group®" in 2000 (Foremost), and Bristol West calls itself "a member of the Farmers Insurance Group of Companies" (Bristol West).
We work with both: Foremost for specialty risks such as manufactured homes and RVs, and Bristol West for drivers who need non-standard auto. That still does not let us quote a Farmers-branded homeowners policy.
Farmers vs. Travelers at a Glance
| Category | Farmers | Travelers |
|---|---|---|
| How it is sold | Farmers exclusive agencies, independent agents and direct online/call center sales across the group (Farmers) | Independent agents (Travelers) |
| AM Best financial strength | A (Excellent), stable, affirmed August 1, 2025 for group members (AM Best release) | A++ (Superior), stable, affirmed August 21, 2026 (AM Best release) |
| Optional coverages it names | Extended Replacement Cost (up to 25% above the limit), Guaranteed Replacement Cost, Building Ordinance or Law, Sewer and Drain Water Damage, Scheduled Personal Articles, Identity Shield (Farmers) | Additional Replacement Cost Protection, water backup and sump pump, equipment breakdown, buried utility lines, identity fraud expense and more (Travelers) |
| Discounts it names | Bundling ("10% or more"), claim free, new home, protective devices, connected home, home safety, green certifications, UL-approved roofing and more (Farmers) | Homebuyer, multi-policy, protective device, loss-free, green home up to 5% (Travelers) |
| Wind/hail and roof | "Some policies include a separate wind or hail deductible"; roof coverage can vary with options and roof age (Farmers) | Not addressed on the Travelers deductible page we reviewed (Travelers); check the quote |
| Texas homeowners market share, 2024 | Farmers Insurance Group 8.15% (TDI) | Travelers Group 5.15% (TDI) |
| Who can quote it for you | A Farmers agent or Farmers directly | An independent agent appointed with Travelers, including us |
How Do Farmers and Travelers Compare on Financial Strength?
On August 21, 2026, AM Best affirmed the Financial Strength Rating of A++ (Superior) for the main Travelers subsidiaries with a stable outlook, according to the AM Best release.
On August 1, 2025, AM Best affirmed the Financial Strength Rating of A (Excellent), with stable outlooks, for members of Farmers Insurance Group, a list that includes Farmers Insurance Exchange, Illinois Farmers Insurance Company, Texas Farmers Insurance Company, the Foremost companies and the Bristol West companies (AM Best release). AM Best called the balance sheet strong and operating performance adequate, while citing elevated catastrophe exposure as an offsetting factor.
Both ratings indicate a strong ability to pay claims. AM Best can update a rating at any time, so check its site for the current one.
What Coverage Options Does Each Company Offer?
Farmers
Farmers' home coverage options page names these add-ons:
- Extended Replacement Cost, which pays "up to 25% above that limit" if rebuilding costs exceed your dwelling limit
- Guaranteed Replacement Cost, for the full cost of covered repairs even above the limit
- Building Ordinance or Law, for code-required upgrades
- Sewer and Drain Water Damage
- Scheduled Personal Articles, for items such as jewelry
- Identity Shield
The page notes that "not all products, coverages and discounts are available in every state."
Travelers
Travelers' home coverage page lists Additional Replacement Cost Protection (see extended replacement cost), personal property replacement cost, equipment breakdown, buried utility lines, water backup and identity fraud expense coverage, among others, noting that availability varies by state.
The add-on we ask about first is water backup coverage, which each company names differently. Match the limit, not just the name.
How Do They Handle Roofs and Wind/Hail?
Farmers' May 13, 2026 release says "some policies include a separate wind or hail deductible" and "roof coverage can vary based on the options selected on a policy and the age of the roof." It adds that hail made up about 31% of its homeowners claim volume from January 2024 through March 2026.
For Texas, Farmers notes that "in Texas's 14 coastal counties, standard home insurance policies may exclude wind and hail damage," and mentions a FORTIFIED Roof™ Upgrade (Farmers Texas). Our guides on Texas wind/hail deductibles and FORTIFIED roof discounts go deeper.
Travelers' public deductibles page explains that you pay your deductible each time you have a covered loss but does not describe a wind/hail deductible or roof rule. When we quote Travelers, we show those terms on the quote. See also ACV vs. replacement cost on roof claims.
Which Discounts Do Farmers and Travelers Offer?
Farmers' homeowners discounts page says you "can save 10% or more by bundling home and at least one other qualifying Farmers policy," and names claim-free (after three claim-free years), new home (under 14 years old), protective devices, home safety, green certifications, UL-approved roofing, affinity and payment discounts. "Discounts vary by state."
Travelers' discounts page names a homebuyer discount, multi-policy, protective device, loss-free, and a green home discount of "up to 5%" for LEED-certified homes.
A longer list does not mean a lower price. See our home insurance discounts guide.
What About Claims Service?
J.D. Power's 2026 U.S. Property Claims Satisfaction Study, released March 17, 2026, put industry homeowners claims satisfaction at 702 on a 1,000-point scale, with Amica ranking highest at 773 (InsuranceNewsNet). The release text we reviewed does not name Farmers or Travelers. For complaint data, look each company up in the NAIC Consumer Insurance Search.
What Has Farmers Done in Texas and Illinois Recently?
The Texas Department of Insurance's market overview lists Farmers Insurance Group with 8.15% of 2024 homeowners premium (listed fourth among groups) and Travelers Group at 5.15% (listed sixth). TDI puts the 2025 average Texas homeowners premium at $3,489 (preliminary); more in our Texas home insurance guide and best home insurance companies in Texas.
In Illinois, we did not find a 2025 or 2026 Farmers homeowners rate action reported by Insurance Journal or the Illinois Department of Insurance. See best home insurance companies in Illinois.
Who Is Each Company a Good Fit For?
Farmers may fit you if you want one Farmers agent for everything, value add-ons such as Guaranteed Replacement Cost, or qualify for several of its listed discounts.
Travelers may fit you if you want endorsements like buried utility lines or equipment breakdown, recently bought your home, or want several carriers priced at once. For other Travelers matchups, see State Farm vs. Travelers and Allstate vs. Travelers, or our Travelers carrier profile.
How Do I Compare Farmers and Travelers Apples to Apples?
Start with your declarations page. Match a Travelers quote on:
- Dwelling limit (Coverage A) and whether extended or guaranteed replacement cost is included
- All-perils deductible and any separate wind/hail deductible (a flat dollar amount vs. a percentage)
- Roof settlement: replacement cost or actual cash value
- Personal property on replacement cost, not actual cash value
- Liability limit
- Endorsements: water backup limit, ordinance or law, service or buried lines, scheduled jewelry
A cheaper quote with a higher wind/hail deductible is a different product, not a better price. Our quote comparison guide walks through the traps.
Get Travelers Quoted Against Your Farmers Policy
We can't quote a Farmers-branded home policy, but we can quote Travelers, Liberty Mutual, Nationwide, Grange, and other carriers we represent side by side with one form, against your Farmers declarations page. Our online quick quote takes about three minutes; a licensed agent calls you back. Quotes are free with no obligation, and for our clients we review every renewal and re-shop when an increase is out of line. If Farmers is still your best value, we will say so.
Ready to compare? Independent agency, 22+ carriers, licensed in 14 states. Mon–Fri, 9 AM–6 PM.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Farmers or Travelers better for home insurance?
Neither is better for every household. Travelers holds an AM Best rating of A++ (Superior), affirmed August 2026, and the Farmers Insurance Group members hold A (Excellent), affirmed August 2025. The right choice depends on the price and terms each offers for your home, so compare identical coverage from both.
Can an independent agent quote Farmers home insurance?
Not the Farmers-branded home policy through our agency. Farmers home insurance is sold through Farmers agents and directly by Farmers, and we are not a Farmers agency. We can quote Travelers and the other carriers we represent against your current Farmers declarations page.
Are Foremost and Bristol West part of Farmers?
Yes. Foremost says it was acquired by the Farmers Insurance Group in 2000, and Bristol West describes itself as a member of the Farmers Insurance Group of Companies. Both are available through independent agencies like ours.
Does Farmers have a separate wind or hail deductible?
It can. A May 2026 Farmers release says some policies include a separate wind or hail deductible and that roof coverage can vary with the options selected and the age of the roof. Check the wind/hail line on your declarations page and match it when comparing quotes.
What optional coverages does Travelers offer on home policies?
Travelers lists Additional Replacement Cost Protection, Personal Property Replacement Cost, Equipment Breakdown, Buried Utility Lines, Water Backup and Sump Pump Discharge or Overflow, and Identity Fraud Expense Reimbursement coverage, among others. Availability varies by state.
Is Travelers cheaper than Farmers?
There is no general answer. Each company weighs your roof, location, claims history and coverage choices differently, so the only way to know is to price identical coverage from both. We can quote Travelers; your Farmers price is on your renewal.
Related Reading
- State Farm vs. Travelers Home Insurance
- Allstate vs. Travelers Home Insurance
- Travelers vs. Nationwide Home Insurance
- Best Home Insurance Companies in Texas
- Best Home Insurance Companies in Illinois
- Travelers: Carrier Profile
About the author
Evan Larson — Licensed Insurance Agent at Better Choice Insurance Group, an independent insurance agency in St. Charles, Illinois licensed in 14 states.
Last reviewed: November 2026